The UK has recently implemented a new migrant deal with France called the 'one in, one out' scheme. This agreement aims to reduce the number of migrants crossing the Channel by deporting some asylum seekers back to France in exchange for accepting others with legitimate claims. As the UK faces record migrant crossings, many are asking how this deal works, why it was introduced, and what impact it might have on migration. Below, we explore the key questions surrounding this controversial policy.
-
What is the 'one in, one out' migrant deal between the UK and France?
The 'one in, one out' deal is an agreement where the UK agrees to deport a migrant to France each time it accepts a migrant with a legitimate asylum claim. The goal is to deter illegal crossings by creating a legal route for some migrants while removing others who arrive illegally. This scheme was signed in July and is part of the UK’s broader strategy to control migration and reduce Channel crossings.
-
Why is the UK deporting families to France now?
The UK has started deporting families to France as part of the new deal to curb illegal crossings. The first family of three was recently deported under this scheme, marking a significant step in its implementation. The government hopes that increased returns will discourage migrants from attempting dangerous crossings, although legal challenges and public debate continue around the policy.
-
How are legal challenges affecting UK migration policies?
Legal challenges have slowed some deportation efforts, with courts blocking certain removals. Critics argue that the legal system is protecting migrants' rights, while supporters believe the government needs to enforce stricter controls. These legal hurdles mean that the scheme is still in its early stages, and its full impact remains uncertain as courts continue to review the legality of removals.
-
What are the current trends in migrant crossings into the UK?
Record numbers of migrants are crossing the Channel into the UK, with over 32,000 arrivals this year alone. Despite the new policies, crossings remain high, highlighting the ongoing challenge for UK authorities. The government is counting on increased deportations and legal routes to reduce these numbers, but the situation remains complex and politically sensitive.
-
Will the 'one in, one out' deal actually reduce crossings?
Proponents believe that scaling up the scheme could cut crossings by up to 75% over three years, based on reports and comparisons with US efforts. However, critics argue that the scheme’s early results are minimal and that legal and logistical challenges could limit its effectiveness. The true impact will only be clear as the scheme is expanded and more data becomes available.
-
What are the political reactions to the UK-France migrant deal?
The deal has received mixed reactions. Supporters, including government officials, see it as a necessary step to control migration and protect public services. Opponents, including opposition politicians and human rights groups, criticize it for potentially violating migrants’ rights and for being ineffective. The debate continues as the UK government pushes to scale up the scheme amid ongoing record crossings.