Recent reports reveal a worrying rise in violence against teachers in Scotland, with over 5,200 incidents recorded between 2019 and 2025. Critics link this surge to changes in school discipline policies and government guidance. Many wonder what’s behind this trend, how policies are affecting school safety, and what can be done to protect educators. Below, we explore the key questions surrounding this concerning issue.
-
Why are attacks on teachers increasing in Scotland?
Data shows a significant rise in violent incidents against teachers over the past few years. Critics argue that the Scottish government’s guidance to prioritize discussion over exclusion has led to less discipline and more disruptions, which can escalate into violence. The decline in exclusion powers and stricter disciplinary measures are seen as contributing factors to the increase in attacks.
-
What does SNP guidance have to do with school violence?
The SNP government’s guidance encourages schools to focus on restorative practices and discussions rather than harsh disciplinary actions like exclusions. While aimed at creating a more inclusive environment, critics say this approach has inadvertently reduced the ability to remove disruptive students, leading to more tensions and violence in classrooms.
-
How is school discipline changing in Scotland?
School discipline policies in Scotland are shifting away from exclusion and punishment towards dialogue and restorative justice. While this aims to improve school climate, some argue it has made it harder to manage disruptive behavior, resulting in increased violence and safety concerns for teachers.
-
What are the safety concerns for teachers?
Teachers are increasingly worried about their safety due to the rise in violent incidents. Many have reported injuries requiring hospital treatment, and some feel that current policies do not do enough to protect staff. The debate continues over whether stricter disciplinary measures or supportive approaches are better for ensuring school safety.
-
Are there solutions to reduce violence in Scottish schools?
Experts suggest that a balanced approach combining restorative practices with appropriate disciplinary measures could help. Increasing support for teachers, better training in managing conflict, and clearer policies on exclusions might also improve safety. Ongoing discussions focus on finding effective ways to protect educators while maintaining inclusive school environments.
-
How do other countries handle school discipline and safety?
Different countries have varied approaches, with some emphasizing strict disciplinary policies and others focusing on restorative justice. Comparing these methods can offer insights into effective strategies for reducing violence and ensuring safe learning environments for both students and teachers.