In December 2025, Florida took a controversial step by designating the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) and the Muslim Brotherhood as foreign terrorist organizations. This move has sparked widespread debate about security, free speech, and civil rights. Many are asking: what prompted this decision, and what does it mean for Muslim communities in the US? Below, we explore the reasons behind Florida's actions, the legal arguments involved, and the broader implications of such designations.
-
Why did Florida label CAIR and the Muslim Brotherhood as terrorists?
Florida's government, led by Governor Ron DeSantis, issued an executive order claiming that CAIR and the Muslim Brotherhood are linked to terrorist activities. The order aims to prevent state agencies from contracting or funding these groups. DeSantis and his supporters argue that these groups pose a security threat, citing allegations of connections to Hamas and other terrorist entities. However, CAIR and many civil rights groups deny these links and argue the designation is politically motivated.
-
What are the legal arguments against Florida's terror group designation?
Critics argue that Florida's designation is unconstitutional because neither CAIR nor the Muslim Brotherhood is federally recognized as a terrorist organization. They contend that the move infringes on free speech and association rights. CAIR has announced plans to sue, claiming the order is defamatory and violates constitutional protections. Legal experts are debating whether the state's actions align with federal law and First Amendment rights.
-
How do these designations impact Muslim communities in the US?
Labeling groups like CAIR as terrorists can have serious repercussions for Muslim communities, including increased suspicion, discrimination, and social stigma. CAIR is a civil rights organization that advocates for Muslim Americans, and such designations may hinder their ability to operate freely. Critics warn that these actions could lead to increased Islamophobia and undermine community trust and safety.
-
Are other states considering similar actions?
Yes, Florida is not the only state to take such steps. Texas has also designated CAIR as a terrorist organization, following similar rhetoric. These moves are part of a broader political trend where some states are adopting stricter measures against groups they associate with terrorism. However, federal law does not currently recognize these groups as terrorist entities, making these state actions controversial and legally complex.
-
What is the background of CAIR and the Muslim Brotherhood?
CAIR, founded in 1994, is the largest Muslim civil rights group in the US, with 25 chapters nationwide. The Muslim Brotherhood is an Islamist organization founded in Egypt, which some US officials have linked to terrorism, though these claims are disputed. Neither CAIR nor the Muslim Brotherhood is officially designated as a terrorist organization by the US federal government, despite allegations and political debates surrounding their activities.