What's happened
Dr. Nesheiwat has withdrawn her nomination for U.S. Surgeon General just before her Senate confirmation hearing. The decision follows scrutiny over her medical credentials and public statements, particularly regarding her support for COVID-19 vaccines. This withdrawal highlights ongoing tensions within the Republican Party regarding public health leadership.
What's behind the headline?
Key Insights
- Controversial Background: Nesheiwat's nomination faced backlash due to questions about her medical education, specifically her claim of graduating from the University of Arkansas School of Medicine instead of the American University of the Caribbean.
- Political Dynamics: The withdrawal reflects internal conflicts within the Republican Party, particularly regarding vaccine skepticism and public health messaging. Critics like Laura Loomer have leveraged her nomination to highlight divisions.
- Implications for Public Health: The Surgeon General plays a crucial role in public health advisories. This withdrawal may signal a reluctance within the party to embrace scientifically backed health policies, potentially impacting future public health initiatives.
- Future of Nominees: The situation raises questions about the vetting process for nominees in the current administration, especially in light of previous withdrawals due to lack of support from key party members.
What the papers say
According to AP News, the withdrawal was confirmed by anonymous sources and highlighted Nesheiwat's controversial background, stating, "Nesheiwat had become a magnet for controversy after a CBS News report called into question whether she’d been forthright about her education and background." The Independent also noted that her nomination was largely based on her media presence rather than her medical qualifications, emphasizing the political motivations behind her selection. Andrew Feinberg from The Independent pointed out that the scrutiny she faced was not just about her qualifications but also about her alignment with vaccine policies, stating, "the possibility that stigma against foreign medical graduates would have led to Nesheiwat’s nomination being withdrawn, or the possibility that it would have been due to her support for vaccines." This illustrates the complex interplay of politics and public health in the current administration.
How we got here
Nesheiwat, a medical director and former Fox News contributor, was nominated to be Surgeon General amid controversies surrounding her educational background and public health stance. Criticism intensified from within the party, particularly from far-right figures.
Go deeper
- What were the main controversies surrounding Nesheiwat?
- How does this impact public health policy?
- Who might be nominated next for Surgeon General?
Common question
More on these topics
-
Donald John Trump is an American politician, media personality, and businessman who served as the 45th president of the United States from 2017 to 2021.
-
The United States of America, commonly known as the United States or America, is a country mostly located in central North America, between Canada and Mexico.
-
Janette Nesheiwat (born 1976) is an American physician who was briefly a nominee for Surgeon General of the United States during the second Trump administration. Nesheiwat has served as the medical director of the healthcare company CityMD and is a former
-
Laura Elizabeth Loomer is an American political activist, conspiracy theorist, and internet personality known for her far-right politics and commentary.
-
David Joseph Weldon is an American politician and physician. He was a Republican member of the United States House of Representatives, representing Florida's 15th congressional district, and was an unsuccessful candidate for the Republican nomination in F