What's happened
Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu has signed orders to revoke the citizenship of two Palestinians convicted of attacks, under a 2023 law allowing citizenship revocation for those receiving Palestinian Authority payments. This marks the law's first implementation, raising concerns over discrimination and potential wider expulsions.
What's behind the headline?
The use of the 2023 law to revoke Palestinian citizenship signals a significant escalation in Israel's legal approach to Palestinian citizens and residents. The law explicitly targets Palestinians, especially those receiving PA payments, and excludes Jewish Israelis, highlighting a racial and political bias. This move effectively institutionalizes discrimination, turning citizenship into a conditional status that can be revoked based on political and security grounds. The timing suggests an electoral motive, with Netanyahu's government seeking to stoke tensions ahead of upcoming elections. Internationally, this policy risks further isolating Israel and violating international law, particularly the Geneva Conventions, which prohibit forcible transfers and deportations of protected persons. The broader legislative context, including the 'Jewish nation-state' law and proposed death penalty, indicates a trend toward legalizing and normalizing systemic marginalization and repression of Palestinians. The potential for wider expulsions of hundreds of detainees and citizens underscores the threat to Palestinian presence and rights within Israel and occupied territories. This strategy will likely deepen existing divisions and provoke international condemnation, while domestically, it consolidates right-wing electoral support by framing Palestinians as threats to national security.
What the papers say
The articles from AP News, The Independent, Al Jazeera, The New Arab, and The Times of Israel collectively reveal a coordinated effort by Netanyahu's government to implement the 2023 citizenship revocation law against Palestinians convicted of attacks. AP News reports that the law's application does not specify deportation destinations, raising concerns about potential statelessness. The Independent highlights the law's discriminatory nature, emphasizing its targeting of Palestinian citizens and residents, and notes critics' fears of increased expulsions. Al Jazeera details Netanyahu's signing of the order to revoke citizenship and the law's first use, framing it as a move rooted in discrimination and electoral strategy. The New Arab underscores the law's broader implications, warning of a dangerous precedent and possible expansion to more detainees. The Times of Israel confirms the law's first implementation, identifying the two Palestinians involved and noting the law's explicit targeting of Palestinians, with Jewish offenders largely exempt. Overall, the sources depict a pattern of legislative and executive actions aimed at marginalizing Palestinians, justified by security concerns but widely criticized as discriminatory and potentially illegal under international law.
How we got here
The 2023 law was passed to facilitate revoking citizenship or residency from Palestinians convicted of acts deemed as terrorism, especially those receiving funds from the Palestinian Authority. Critics argue it institutionalizes discrimination, targeting Palestinians specifically, and is part of broader legislative efforts to marginalize Palestinian citizens and residents within Israel and occupied territories. The law builds on existing legislation from 1952, which already allowed revocation for 'breach of loyalty.' The move follows a series of legislative measures aimed at tightening control over Palestinian populations, including a proposed death penalty bill and land seizure policies in the West Bank.
Go deeper
More on these topics
-
Benjamin Netanyahu is an Israeli politician serving as Prime Minister of Israel since 2009, and previously from 1996 to 1999. Netanyahu is also the Chairman of the Likud – National Liberal Movement.
-
Ofir Katz is an Israeli politician. He is currently a member of the Knesset for Likud.
-
The Palestinian National Authority is the interim self-government body established in 1994 following the Gaza–Jericho Agreement to govern the Gaza Strip and Areas A and B of the West Bank, as a consequence of the 1993 Oslo Accords.