What's happened
England's GPs will now be urged to reconsider diagnoses after three appointments without a diagnosis, following the launch of Jess's Rule. Named after Jessica Brady, who died of cancer after multiple visits, the system aims to prevent missed serious illnesses by prompting face-to-face exams, second opinions, or additional tests.
What's behind the headline?
The launch of Jess's Rule marks a significant shift in primary care practice, emphasizing the importance of re-evaluation when symptoms persist. By institutionalizing a 'three strikes' policy, the NHS aims to reduce missed diagnoses of serious illnesses like cancer. This approach challenges the traditional reliance on initial assessments, recognizing that rare or atypical presentations often require a second look. The involvement of Jess's parents and the co-design of the posters reflect a patient-centered movement that seeks to empower both clinicians and patients. However, the policy's success depends on consistent implementation across thousands of practices and overcoming potential resource constraints. The story also highlights ongoing issues with virtual consultations, which can delay diagnosis, especially during pandemic restrictions. Overall, Jess's Rule is poised to save lives by fostering a culture of thoroughness and vigilance in primary care, but its long-term impact will depend on how well it is adopted and integrated into routine practice.
What the papers say
The Guardian reports that Jess's Rule was launched to prevent missed diagnoses, emphasizing the importance of rethinking after three appointments. Sky News highlights the systemic issues faced during the pandemic, which delayed Jess Brady's diagnosis and underscores the need for such policies. The Independent details the story of Jessica Brady, her repeated GP visits, and the tragic outcome, framing the rule as a vital step toward patient safety. All sources agree that the initiative is a response to preventable deaths and is supported by Jess's family, with NHS officials stressing its potential to save lives. Contrasts lie in the depth of analysis: The Guardian focuses on policy implications, Sky News on systemic healthcare challenges, and The Independent on the personal story and emotional impact.
How we got here
Jessica Brady, an Airbus engineer, contacted her GP 20 times over six months with symptoms like abdominal pain and weight loss. Due to pandemic restrictions, she received virtual care and was misdiagnosed with long Covid. Her cancer was only diagnosed after her mother paid for private care, but she died three weeks later. Jess's story prompted the new 'three strikes and we rethink' approach to improve early diagnosis and prevent similar tragedies.
Go deeper
More on these topics
-
Claire Fuller is an author who won the 2015 Desmond Elliott Prize for her debut novel Our Endless Numbered Days. She also won the BBC Opening Lines Short Story Competition in 2014 and the Royal Academy & Pin Drop Short Story Award in 2016.
-
Wesley Paul William Streeting is a British politician serving as the Member of Parliament for Ilford North since 2015, and since 2020 as Shadow Minister for Schools.