What's happened
The sequel to 'Wicked' has been released, featuring new songs, extended scenes, and a mostly unseen Dorothy. Critics praise performances but criticize storytelling and departure from stage magic. The film emphasizes deeper character exploration and introduces a new Dorothy portrayed through silhouette and distant shots.
What's behind the headline?
The 'Wicked: For Good' film underscores a strategic shift from stage to screen, prioritizing character depth and expanded storytelling over visual spectacle. The decision to keep Dorothy’s face unseen aligns with the narrative focus on Elphaba and Glinda, emphasizing their journeys rather than Dorothy’s identity. Critics highlight that the film's extended runtime and new songs aim to flesh out offstage moments, but some argue this dilutes the magic of the original story. The inclusion of new characters and backstories, such as the Munchkin origins and the political framing of Nessarose’s death, reflect a desire to recontextualize Oz’s lore, though some see it as overcomplicated and lacking the charm of the stage version. The departure from the iconic ruby slippers and the focus on more nuanced character arcs suggest a move toward a more mature, introspective adaptation, which may appeal to adult audiences but risks alienating traditional fans. Overall, the film will likely influence future adaptations of musical classics, emphasizing character-driven narratives and expanded musical content, but it may also face criticism for losing the simplicity and magic that made the original so beloved.
What the papers say
The sources present contrasting views: Business Insider UK highlights the film's focus on silhouette casting and the decision to keep Dorothy’s face unseen, emphasizing the storytelling intent. The New York Times praises Erivo's vocal performance and the emotional depth of the extended second act, while also noting the film's departure from the stage's simplicity. Conversely, The Scotsman criticizes the film's over-complication and loss of magic, describing it as a 'stretched-thin, creatively confused epic.' The NY Post appreciates the performances but notes the film's emotional intensity may not appeal to children. Overall, the sources reflect a divide between appreciation for the performances and criticism of the narrative choices and storytelling depth.
How we got here
The 'Wicked' film adaptation was split into two parts, with the second extending the original musical's content through new scenes and songs. Director Jon M. Chu aimed to deepen character development and include new musical numbers, such as 'The Girl in the Bubble' and 'No Place Like Home.' The casting of Bethany Weaver as Dorothy was kept secret until the premiere, emphasizing her silhouette and youthful energy during auditions. The film also departs from the classic ruby slippers, following the original book's depiction.
Go deeper
More on these topics
-
Ariana Grande-Butera is an American singer, songwriter, and actress. Born in Boca Raton, Florida, Grande began her career in the 2008 Broadway musical 13.
-
Cynthia Chinasaokwu Onyedinmanasu Amarachukwu Owezuke Echimino Erivo ( ə-REE-voh; born 8 January 1987) is an English actress, singer, and songwriter. Known for her work on both stage and screen, she is the recipient of several accolades and one of few..
-
Jonathan Murray Chu is an American film and television director, producer and screenwriter. He is best known as the director of 2018's Crazy Rich Asians, the first film by a major Hollywood studio to feature a majority cast of Asian descent in a modern se
-
Jeffrey Lynn Goldblum ( GOHLD-bloom; born October 22, 1952) is an American actor and musician. He has starred in some of the highest-grossing films of all time, such as Jurassic Park (1993) and Independence Day (1996), as well as their sequels.
Goldblum.
-
Colman Jason Domingo is an American actor, writer, director and producer. He is best known for his role as Victor Strand in AMC's Fear the Walking Dead.
-
Michelle Yeoh Choo Kheng Todt (née Yeoh Choo Kheng, Chinese: 楊紫瓊; born 6 August 1962), known professionally as Michelle Yeoh ( YOH), is a Malaysian actress. In a career spanning over four decades, she has acted in film and television productions co
-
Stephen Lawrence Schwartz (born March 6, 1948) is an American musical theatre composer and lyricist. In a career spanning over five decades, Schwartz has written hit musicals including Godspell (1971), Pippin (1972), and Wicked (2003). He has contributed.