What's happened
A new survey shows residents of major US cities are less hopeful about the country's future, despite claims of rising crime. Rural areas remain optimistic, driven by economic concerns and perceptions of Trump's policies. The survey highlights shifting priorities across community types.
What's behind the headline?
The survey reveals a stark contrast between urban and rural outlooks. Urban residents' optimism has decreased from 55% to 45%, reflecting concerns over economic stability and democratic polarization. Conversely, rural areas, especially those classified as 'Rural Middle America,' show increased hope, rising from 43% to 60%, driven by belief in Trump's economic promises.
This divergence underscores a broader political and social divide. Urban pessimism correlates with worries about inflation, healthcare, and democratic stability, which are amplified by recent inflation data showing a 3% rise in consumer prices. Rural optimism, however, is fueled by perceptions that Trump's policies will improve economic conditions, despite evidence that many rural areas haven't experienced significant growth.
The survey also challenges Trump's narrative of urban chaos, as data indicates violent crime has declined in major cities, yet political rhetoric continues to emphasize lawlessness. This disconnect suggests that political messaging is shaping perceptions more than actual crime rates.
Looking ahead, these contrasting outlooks could deepen political polarization, influencing voting patterns and policy debates. Urban areas may push for reforms addressing democratic and social issues, while rural communities may double down on economic nationalism and support for Trump-style policies. The survey signals a potential realignment of political priorities based on regional identities and economic experiences.
What the papers say
The Independent articles from November 17 and 18, 2025, provide detailed insights into the survey's findings. The articles highlight that despite President Trump's claims of urban crime out of control, residents in large metropolitan areas are less concerned about crime than in previous years. Both articles emphasize the decline in urban optimism and the rise in rural hope, driven by economic concerns and perceptions of Trump's policies. The coverage also notes that inflation remains a widespread worry, with consumer prices rising at an annual rate of 3% in September, impacting public sentiment. The articles collectively suggest that political narratives may be diverging from actual data, with urban residents feeling less hopeful and rural communities more optimistic about the future.
How we got here
The American Communities Project (ACP) and Ipsos conducted a survey categorising US counties into 15 community types, analysing local moods based on demographics like race, income, and religion. The survey aims to understand regional differences in concerns such as crime, economy, and optimism, amid political debates and economic challenges.
Go deeper
More on these topics