What's happened
Two years after the 2023 attack that shocked the Jewish world, Israel's response and the global Jewish community's support have evolved. The conflict's aftermath has deepened divisions within Jewish communities worldwide, affecting perceptions of Zionism and Israel's political direction amid rising antisemitism and diplomatic challenges.
What's behind the headline?
The evolving landscape of Jewish support for Israel reflects a complex interplay of historical, political, and social factors. The recent assessments reveal a community grappling with its identity amid ongoing conflict. The decline in American Jewish consensus on Zionism signals a broader reevaluation of Israel's policies and its regional role. The rise in antisemitism and diplomatic isolation post-October 2023 will likely accelerate internal debates, pushing some communities toward critical positions while others reinforce support. The internal polarization over Israel's military actions and political direction suggests that the community's future cohesion depends on how Israel navigates its internal and external crises. The global Jewish community's support is now more fragile, with the potential to reshape longstanding alliances and perceptions of Zionism itself. The next phase will see increased advocacy for diplomatic solutions and internal reforms, but the risk of further fragmentation remains high.
What the papers say
The Guardian's articles provide a detailed historical context, emphasizing the deep roots of Zionist support and its recent fractures. They highlight how the 1967 Six-Day War transformed American Jewish attitudes, turning support into a near-universal consensus among non-Orthodox groups, but also note the growing internal dissent. The recent assessment from the Times of Israel underscores the internal and external challenges Israel faces post-October 2023, including diplomatic isolation, rising antisemitism, and political polarization. It also offers strategic recommendations for Israel to address these issues, emphasizing the importance of internal reform and diplomatic initiatives. The contrasting perspectives reveal a community at a crossroads: one that is deeply rooted in history but increasingly divided over its future direction, with external pressures intensifying the debate.
How we got here
The 2023 attack against Israel prompted a military response that included the destruction of Gaza, which complicated global perceptions of Israel's actions. Historically, American Jewish support for Israel was rooted in shared oppression and Zionist ideals, which have since fractured amid ongoing conflicts and political shifts. The 1967 Six-Day War marked a turning point, solidifying Zionist support but also leading to increased occupation and regional tensions. Over decades, American Jewish attitudes shifted from opposition to Zionism to widespread support, influenced by Israel's military victories and regional security concerns. Recent events, including the October 2023 Hamas attack, have challenged this support, exposing internal divisions and raising questions about the future of Zionism and Israel's regional strategy.
Go deeper
More on these topics
-
Israel, formally known as the State of Israel, is a country in Western Asia, located on the southeastern shore of the Mediterranean Sea and the northern shore of the Red Sea.