What's happened
Twenty-five years after Freedman's 'Jew vs. Jew,' internal Jewish conflicts have intensified, driven by the Gaza war. Diverging views on Zionism, antisemitism, and Israel's policies are splitting American Jewry, with younger generations and Orthodox communities at the forefront of the divide.
What's behind the headline?
The Gaza war has sharply intensified internal Jewish divisions, revealing a fundamental rift over Zionism and Israel's policies. Freedman's earlier thesis that external threats receded has been challenged, as internal conflicts now dominate. The emergence of anti-Zionist groups like Jewish Voice for Peace and If Not Now, especially among younger Jews, signals a generational shift that questions traditional attachments to Israel. The Orthodox community, exemplified by Blau's open letter, demonstrates a split between staunch pro-Israel advocates and those critical of Israeli government actions. This polarization is driven by broader political trends, with the right amplifying divisions and the left grappling with internal dissent. The internal discourse risks weakening communal cohesion and complicates American Jewry's collective identity, with potential long-term consequences for diaspora-Israel relations. The debate over antisemitism, Zionism, and Israel's moral standing will likely persist, shaping Jewish communal politics for years to come. The challenge now is whether these divisions will lead to a redefinition of Jewish identity or further fragmentation.
What the papers say
The Times of Israel provides a nuanced view of how the Gaza conflict has deepened existing divides, emphasizing the internal discourse among American Jews and the impact on Zionist identity. The article highlights the generational and ideological splits, especially among Orthodox and anti-Zionist groups, illustrating how recent events have intensified these fissures. Meanwhile, the NY Post's coverage of Kehillat Israel's break with Reconstructionism underscores the ideological polarization within American Judaism, with progressive movements distancing themselves from Zionist principles. Both sources reveal a broader trend: the internal debate over Israel's morality and policies is reshaping Jewish communal life, with some leaders and communities taking a more critical stance, while others remain unwavering in their support. The contrasting perspectives underscore the complexity of the current Jewish identity crisis, driven by political, religious, and generational factors, and suggest that these divisions will continue to influence Jewish politics and community cohesion in the near future.
How we got here
Freedman's 'Jew vs. Jew' highlighted internal conflicts within American Jewry, initially centered on Orthodox versus non-Orthodox communities and attitudes toward Israel. The 2000s saw shifts with the collapse of the peace process and rising political polarization. The recent Gaza conflict has further fractured these divisions, especially among younger Jews and anti-Zionist groups, reflecting broader societal polarization and changing perceptions of Israel.
Go deeper
More on these topics