What's happened
New Zealand has maintained its long unbeaten run against Scotland with a 43-21 Nations Championship win at Murrayfield. Scotland led 21-24 at half-time but were unable to score in the second half as the All Blacks tightened defensively and added three tries. Ewan Ashman’s first-half hat-trick could not prevent defeat as Scotland prepare for next week’s clash with the Wallabies.
What's behind the headline?
Analysis
- New Zealand’s second-half discipline and defensive structure dominated after a lively first 40 minutes, turning a 21-24 deficit into a comfortable win.
- Scotland’s indiscipline and conversion issues in the red zone limited their scoring after the break, even with a historic first-half hat-trick from Ewan Ashman.
- Coach Townsend faces pressure to deliver a stronger performance against Australia; the maths of the schedule means back-to-back tests will define the Nations Championship prospects for Scotland.
- The broader implication is that the southern-hemisphere teams remain class apart in this format, with the All Blacks showing why they have been dominant in this fixture historically.
How we got here
Scotland hosted New Zealand in the Nations Championship at Murrayfield. The All Blacks built a lead after a high-scoring first half, then controlled the second half to claim a convincing victory. Townsend’s side had shown earlier promise but could not sustain pressure into the final period.
Our analysis
The Guardian reports on Townsend’s frustration and Scotland’s inability to convert pressure into points in the second half. BBC and The Scotsman detail Ashman’s hat-trick and the strategic issues in Scotland’s discipline. The Scotsman also notes Townsend’s willingness to rotate and refine the squad ahead of Australia.
Go deeper
- What changes will Townsend implement for the Australia game?
- Can Scotland arrest their second-half drought in this tournament?
- Will Ashman’s performance become a blueprint for national team selection?
More on these topics
-
New Zealand - Country in Oceania
New Zealand is an island country in the southwestern Pacific Ocean. It comprises two main landmasses—the North Island and the South Island —and around 600 smaller islands, covering a total area of 268,021 square kilometres.
-
Ewan Ashman - Scottish rugby union hooker
Ewan Philip Fraser Ashman (born 3 April 2000) is a professional rugby union player who plays as a hooker for United Rugby Championship club Edinburgh Rugby. Born in Canada and raised in England, he plays for the Scotland national team.
-
Gregor Townsend - Scottish rugby union coach and former player
Gregor Peter John Townsend (born 26 April 1973) is a Scottish professional rugby union coach and former player who has been head coach of the Scotland national team since 2017. Townsend was previously an assistant coach from 2009 to 2012. As a player, he won 82 caps for Scotland and two for the British Lions. He is a former coach of Glasgow Warriors and was a player-coach for Border Reivers. As well as in Scotland, he played club rugby in Australia, England, France and South Africa. As coach of Scotland, his team won at Twickenham for the first time in 38 years in 2021. Townsend was attack coach for the 2021 British & Irish Lions tour to South Africa. Townsend was awarded an MBE in 1999 for services to rugby.
-
Beauden Barrett - New Zealand rugby union player
Beauden John Barrett is a New Zealand rugby union player. He plays at First Five-Eighth position and fullback for Taranaki in the Mitre 10 Cup, the Blues in Super Rugby and New Zealand's national team, the All Blacks.
-
Murrayfield Stadium - Rugby stadium in Edinburgh, Scotland, UK
Murrayfield Stadium is a rugby union stadium located in the area of the same name in Edinburgh, Scotland. The stadium is owned by the Scottish Rugby Union (SRU) and serves as its headquarters, and is the national stadium of the Scotland national rugby union team. With a seating capacity of 67,144, it is the largest stadium in Scotland, the fifth largest in the United Kingdom, and the twenty-second largest in Europe. It officially opened on 21 March 1925 with a game between Scotland and England. The game was won by Scotland who emerged victorious following a Grand Slam. The stadium hosts the majority of Scotland's home test matches and the Scottish Hydro Electric Cup final, as well as certain Edinburgh Rugby matches in the URC and European Rugby Champions Cup. Though primarily a rugby union stadium, Murrayfield has in the past hosted American football, rugby league and association football matches, as well as numerous music concerts. Currently, the stadium is known as Scottish Gas Murrayfield Stadium for sponsorship reasons.
-
Scotland - Country of the United Kingdom
Scotland is a country that is part of the United Kingdom. Covering the northern third of the island of Great Britain, mainland Scotland has a 96 mile border with England to the southeast and is otherwise surrounded by the Atlantic Ocean to the north and w
-
Kyle Steyn - Rugby union player
Kyle Douglas Steyn is a Scotland international rugby union player. His regular position is centre or wing
-
Sione Tuipulotu - Wikimedia disambiguation page
Sione Tuipulotu or Sione Tui'pulotu may refer to: Sione Tuipulotu (rugby union, born February 1997), Australian-born Scottish international rugby union player Sione Tuipulotu (rugby union, born December 1997), New Zealand-born Tongan international rugby.
-
Scotland national rugby union team - Men’s rugby union team representing Scotland
The Scotland national rugby union team represents Scotland in men's international rugby union. Governed by the Scottish Rugby Union, the team takes part in the annual Six Nations Championship and the Rugby World Cup every four years. Scotland's home games are almost always played at Murrayfield Stadium in Edinburgh. Scotland played the first official international test match, winning 1–0 against England at Raeburn Place. Scotland competed in the Five Nations from the inaugural tournament in 1883, winning it 14 times outright (including the final iteration in 1999) and sharing it eight times. However, they have never won the Six Nations since its 2000 inauguration. Scotland have competed in all ten iterations of the Rugby World Cup; their best finish came in 1991, when they lost to New Zealand in the third place play-off. They have beaten all major rugby union nations with the exception of New Zealand, with whom they have had two draws. As of 19 October 2026, Scotland are sixth in the World Rugby Rankings.