What's happened
New York City Mayor-elect Mamdani's official team photo was digitally edited to remove senior adviser Da Costa after her past antisemitic social media posts were exposed. The magazine's editors decided to airbrush her out, sparking controversy over transparency and editorial practices amid Mamdani's swearing-in and policy focus.
What's behind the headline?
The editing of Da Costa from the official photo highlights ongoing tensions between transparency and political image management. The magazine's decision to airbrush her out, without consulting Mamdani's team, raises questions about editorial independence and the ethics of digital manipulation. This incident underscores the sensitivity around past antisemitic remarks, especially when they surface during a political transition. Mamdani's administration faces the challenge of balancing public accountability with political optics. The controversy may influence future media practices and the administration's efforts to address antisemitism and social cohesion in New York City. The incident also reflects broader debates about social media accountability and the impact of historical remarks on contemporary politics. Moving forward, the administration's response to this controversy will shape its credibility and community relations.
What the papers say
The New York Times reports that the original photo was taken on December 17, the day Mamdani announced Da Costa's appointment, and that she resigned the following day after her antisemitic posts were exposed. The magazine's editors decided to remove her from the image without consulting Mamdani's staff, citing the need for the photo to accurately represent his inner circle. The Times emphasizes that most news organizations have strict guidelines against digitally altering images, and the omission was not disclosed in the magazine's caption. The Independent details Da Costa's social media posts and her expressed remorse, noting Mamdani's public stance against antisemitism. The Times of Israel highlights the political context of Mamdani's swearing-in as the first Muslim mayor of New York and the subsequent controversy over the altered photograph, which was shot by celebrity photographer Mark Seliger. The articles collectively illustrate the tension between political image management and journalistic integrity, with some sources criticizing the lack of transparency and others focusing on the broader implications for social cohesion and media ethics.
How we got here
Da Costa, Mamdani's senior adviser, resigned after her antisemitic social media posts from 2011 and 2012 were revealed. The posts included derogatory comments about Jews and references to Jewish communities. Mamdani, the city's first Muslim mayor, has publicly expressed remorse for her remarks. The incident coincided with Mamdani's swearing-in and the publication of a magazine cover featuring his inner circle, which was later altered to exclude Da Costa.
Go deeper
More on these topics