What's happened
The NEA voted to cease using ADL materials, citing concerns over pro-Israel bias and distortion of antisemitism data. The move reflects growing criticism of the ADL's stance on Israel and its influence in education, amid debates over hate and civil rights in US schools.
What's behind the headline?
The NEA's decision to cut ties with the ADL marks a significant shift in the landscape of civil rights and hate education in US schools. The move underscores a growing skepticism among educators and progressive groups about the ADL's pro-Israel advocacy, which they argue distorts the understanding of antisemitism by conflating criticism of Israel with hatred toward Jews. This controversy reveals a deeper divide over how hate and bias are defined and addressed in educational settings. The NEA's stance may embolden other unions and institutions to scrutinize the ADL's role, potentially leading to a reevaluation of its influence in curriculum and policy. The decision also reflects broader political tensions surrounding Israel and Palestine, with some viewing the ADL's support for Israel as incompatible with a balanced approach to human rights. Moving forward, the debate will likely intensify over the role of advocacy organizations in shaping educational content and civil rights policies, with implications for how hate crimes and bias are understood and addressed in schools. The outcome of this internal review by the NEA's executive committee will be pivotal in determining whether this marks a lasting shift or a temporary divergence.
What the papers say
The Times of Israel reports that the NEA's move was supported by a slim majority and will be reviewed by its executive committee, highlighting concerns over the ADL's influence and bias, especially regarding Israel and Palestine. The NY Post emphasizes the importance of the ADL's anti-hate programs and criticizes the NEA's decision as a distraction from pressing issues like overcrowded classrooms and funding. The NY Post also underscores the ADL's long history of civil rights work and its role in fostering safe learning environments, framing the NEA's move as a politically motivated rejection of an organization that fights all forms of hate. Meanwhile, The Times of Israel notes the criticism from progressive Jewish groups and the broader political context, including the impact of the Israel-Hamas conflict on perceptions of the ADL. The contrasting perspectives reveal a debate over the ADL's credibility and the appropriate boundaries of advocacy in education, with some viewing the organization as essential for combating hate, and others as biased and politicized.
How we got here
The NEA's decision follows a broader movement questioning the ADL's role in education and its pro-Israel advocacy. The union's 2025 Representative Assembly in Portland saw a slim majority support the measure, which will now be reviewed by the NEA's executive committee. The ADL has historically provided anti-hate education and data, but recent criticism from progressives and Jewish groups accuses it of bias and politicization, especially regarding Israel and Palestine. The controversy intensified after the Israel-Hamas conflict, with some accusing the ADL of inflating hate crime statistics and opposing pro-Palestine movements. The NEA's move signals a shift in how some US educators view the organization amid concerns over its influence and impartiality.
Go deeper
Common question
-
Why is the NEA cutting ties with the ADL?
The National Education Association (NEA) recently voted to stop using materials from the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), sparking questions about why this move was made. This decision reflects ongoing debates over how antisemitism, civil rights, and political influences are handled in US education. Many wonder what this means for students, teachers, and the broader fight against hate in schools. Below, we explore the reasons behind this decision and what implications it might have.
More on these topics
-
The National Education Association is the largest labor union and professional interest group in the United States.
It represents public school teachers and other support personnel, faculty and staffers at colleges and universities, retired educators, and
-
The Anti-Defamation League (ADL), formerly known as the Anti-Defamation League of B'nai B'rith, is a New York-based international non-governmental organization that was founded to combat antisemitism, as well as other forms of bigotry and discrimination..