What's happened
New York Governor Kathy Hochul advocates for expanded authority for physician assistants, risking increased diagnostic errors. This contrasts with the UK’s recent move to restrict PAs after a fatal misdiagnosis, highlighting ongoing debates over PAs' roles and patient safety.
What's behind the headline?
The push for greater PA independence in New York reflects a broader trend to address healthcare workforce shortages, especially in primary care. However, the evidence suggests that PAs' shorter training—typically two to three years—limits their diagnostic accuracy compared to physicians, who undergo extensive medical education and residency. The Syracuse University study indicates that this truncated training correlates with higher diagnostic error rates, raising concerns about patient safety.
Meanwhile, the UK’s recent policy reversal to restrict PAs from treating undiagnosed patients underscores the risks associated with overextending their scope. The tragic death of actress Emily Chesterton, misdiagnosed by a PA, exemplifies the dangers of insufficient training and oversight.
The contrasting approaches highlight a critical debate: balancing healthcare access with quality and safety. While expanding PA roles can reduce wait times and costs, it should not compromise diagnostic accuracy. Policymakers must weigh the benefits of increased workforce flexibility against the potential for preventable errors, which could undermine public trust and patient outcomes. The future of PA practice will likely depend on stricter regulations and clearer communication about their scope of practice to ensure safety without hindering access.
What the papers say
The New York Times emphasizes the evolving role of PAs and the push for independence, noting that they now practice across all specialties with more autonomy, which raises safety concerns. Conversely, the NY Post highlights recent tragedies, including a lawsuit over a fatal misdiagnosis, and contrasts this with the UK’s decision to limit PAs after a similar fatality. The NY Post underscores that diagnosis remains the critical safety point, with evidence from Syracuse University showing higher diagnostic errors among PAs due to shorter training. Both sources agree that the debate centers on balancing access and safety, but differ in tone: The NY Times presents the expansion as a natural evolution, while the NY Post warns of the dangers and calls for caution.
How we got here
Physician assistants (PAs) were created in the 1960s to address doctor shortages, initially assisting under supervision. Over time, their roles expanded, with many practicing independently across specialties. Recent legislative efforts aim to further increase their autonomy, sparking controversy over diagnostic safety and quality of care.
Go deeper
More on these topics