What's happened
On March 18, 2025, Mexico City's congress voted to ban traditional bullfighting, replacing it with a bloodless alternative. The legislation prohibits killing bulls and using sharp objects, aiming to protect animal rights while maintaining the economic aspects of the bullfighting industry. Protests erupted from supporters of the traditional practice.
What's behind the headline?
Legislative Shift
The recent legislation marks a significant shift in Mexico City's approach to bullfighting, reflecting changing societal values regarding animal rights.
Economic Considerations
- Job Preservation: Proponents argue that the bullfighting industry supports tens of thousands of jobs, making economic considerations a key factor in the legislation.
- Cultural Tradition: Bullfighting has deep cultural roots in Mexico, complicating the transition to non-violent alternatives.
Public Response
- Support and Opposition: The vote has sparked protests from traditionalists, indicating a divided public opinion. Supporters of the ban, including Mayor Clara Brugada, emphasize the need for animal welfare.
- Future of Bullfighting: The success of bloodless bullfights remains uncertain, as critics doubt their appeal to traditional fans.
Conclusion
This legislation will likely set a precedent for other regions grappling with similar issues, balancing cultural traditions with evolving ethical standards regarding animal treatment.
What the papers say
According to The Guardian, the new law prohibits the killing of bulls and the use of sharp objects, with Mayor Clara Brugada stating, "The spectacle of blood cannot be justified under any concept of art and tradition." Meanwhile, AP News reported that the decision was met with protests from bullfighting supporters, who expressed their pride in the tradition. The Independent echoed these sentiments, highlighting the economic implications of the ban, noting that bullfighting generates significant employment. The South China Morning Post added that the bill aims to evolve bullfighting rather than eliminate it, suggesting a compromise in a contentious debate.
How we got here
The decision follows years of debate over bullfighting in Mexico, which has faced increasing scrutiny for animal cruelty. A previous ban was overturned by the Supreme Court in 2023, allowing bullfighting to resume. The new legislation is seen as a compromise between animal rights advocates and traditionalists.
Go deeper
- What are the economic impacts of this ban?
- How have animal rights groups reacted to the legislation?
- What does this mean for the future of bullfighting in Mexico?
Common question
-
What are the changes in Mexico City's new bullfighting legislation?
On March 18, 2025, Mexico City lawmakers passed a significant bill aimed at transforming the practice of bullfighting. This legislation has sparked a mix of celebration and protest, raising questions about animal rights, cultural identity, and the future of bullfighting in Mexico. Below, we explore the key aspects of this new law and its implications.
More on these topics
-
Clara Marina Brugada Molina is a Mexican politician, member of the National Regeneration Movement Party. She is currently serving as Chief of the Office of the Iztapalapa borough in Mexico City.
-
Mexico City is the capital and largest city of Mexico and the most-populous city in North America. Mexico City is one of the most important cultural and financial centres in the world.
