Backlash to Government U-turn on Jury Trials

What's happened

The government has reversed Keir Starmer-era plans to curb jury trials for cases likely to yield sentences under three years, amid a backlog crisis that implicates victims and defendants. Justice Secretary Alex Norris says the change responds to strong public concern, maintaining some judge-only powers for complex cases while expanding magistrates’ scope in less serious matters.

What's behind the headline?

Brief

• The U-turn signals a recalibration of how quickly the system can move without eroding public confidence in jury trials.
• Critics warn the move could shift 25,000 cases per year away from crown court, straining magistrates already at capacity.
• The government insists the change is aimed at delivering swifter justice while protecting victims and witnesses.

What this means

• Jury rights remain for the most serious indictable offences; most mid-level cases will proceed without juries in crown court, with magistrates handling many minor offences.
• The backlog remains a driving factor. The government argues time saved in setting up new divisions outweighs potential risks to trial integrity.
• Legal bodies warn that more power for magistrates could exacerbate disparities among vulnerable groups if not properly supported.

Forecast

• Expect ongoing debate about efficacy of judge-alone trials in reducing delays. Further legislation and funding will determine whether the backlog stabilises or grows again.

How we got here

This week’s policy shift follows a dramatic pushback from lawyers and victims’ groups to Starmer-era reforms aimed at reducing jury trials. The backlog in crown courts has surged to near 81,000 cases, with projections touching 100,000 before the next election. The MoJ will still allow judge-only trials for some lengthy fraud cases and will extend magistrates’ powers in certain offences as part of a broader reform package.

Our analysis

The BBC reports a shift in policy, noting the government’s claim that victims’ justice will be accelerated while acknowledging concerns from the Criminal Bar Association and Bar Council. Reuters and The Guardian provide parallel accounts, highlighting the political pressures and the persistent backlog of cases. All articles underscore anger from lawyers at any erosion of jury rights and emphasize the systemic funding challenge.

Go deeper

• Will this reform actually reduce the crown court backlog, or simply move cases to magistrates’ courts?
• How will magistrates’ increased sentencing powers affect fairness and outcomes for minority communities?
• What protections remain for victims and witnesses amid broader reforms?

More on these topics

• David Lammy - Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom

  David Lindon Lammy PC FRSA is a British Labour Party politician serving as Member of Parliament for Tottenham since 2000, and has served as Shadow Secretary of State for Justice and Shadow Lord Chancellor in Keir Starmer's Shadow Cabinet since 2020.

• Kirsty Brimelow - British QC

  Kirsty Brimelow is a barrister of England and Wales and KC practising from Doughty Street Chambers. She is elected Chair of the Bar Council of England and Wales 2026, having served a year as Vice Chair. She practises in the national and international courts and tribunals in international human rights, criminal law and public law. She is a Bencher of Gray's Inn and was an elected member of its management committee. She was International Pro Bono Barrister of the Year in 2018 and was Chair of the Bar Human Rights Committee (2012–2018). She obtained an LLB Hons from Birmingham University and then studied at the Inns of Court School of Law to be called to the Bar in 1991. She was a pupil at Littleton Chambers in 1993. She was appointed Queen’s Counsel in 2011. In 2021 she was appointed trustee of WWF UK. In 2021, she was elected Vice-Chair of the Criminal Bar Association of England and Wales. She was Chair of the Criminal Bar Association from 1 September 2022- 1 September 2023. She became Chair when criminal barristers were engaged in an historic all-out strike. She opened and led negotiations with the government which resulted in a 15% increase in defence fees on ongoing and future cases...

• Keir Starmer - Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom

  Sir Keir Rodney Starmer KCB QC MP is a British politician and former lawyer who has served as Leader of the Labour Party and Leader of the Opposition since 2020. He has been Member of Parliament for Holborn and St Pancras since 2015.

• Bar Council - Professional body of barristers

  A bar council (Irish: Comhairle an Bharra) or bar association, in a common law jurisdiction with a legal profession split between solicitors and barristers or advocates, is a professional body that regulates the profession of barristers. In such jurisdict

• England and Wales - Administrative jurisdiction within the United Kingdom

  England and Wales is one of the three legal jurisdictions of the United Kingdom. It covers the constituent countries England and Wales and was formed by the Laws in Wales Acts 1535 and 1542. The substantive law of the jurisdiction is English law.

• Andy Burnham - Mayor of Greater Manchester

  Andrew Murray Burnham is a British Labour Party politician who has served as Mayor of Greater Manchester since 2017. He attended Gordon Brown’s Cabinet as Chief Secretary to the Treasury from 2007 to 2008 and served in the Cabinet as Culture Secretary f

• Alex Norris - Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom

  Alexander James Jordan Norris is a British Labour and Co-operative Party politician. He is the Member of Parliament for Nottingham North, and was first elected at the 2017 general election.

• Crown Court - Court of justice

  The Crown Court of England and Wales is, together with the High Court of Justice and the Court of Appeal, one of the constituent parts of the Senior Courts of England and Wales.