What's happened
Maurizio Cattelan's iconic 18-karat gold toilet, 'America,' will be auctioned at Sotheby’s on November 18. The fully functional sculpture, made from over 223 pounds of gold, is a social commentary on wealth and art. It will be displayed at Sotheby’s New York headquarters but cannot be used this time.
What's behind the headline?
The auction of Cattelan's 'America' exemplifies the ongoing debate about art's intrinsic value versus its material worth. The work's transformation from a social critique to a high-value commodity highlights how art can be commodified, especially when linked to luxury materials like gold. The piece's history of theft and the fact that it remains a functional object complicate its valuation, blurring lines between art, utility, and theft. Sotheby’s positioning it as a commentary on wealth underscores the provocative nature of Cattelan’s work, which consistently challenges perceptions of value. The auction will likely set a new benchmark for the value of conceptual art made from precious materials, reinforcing the idea that art's worth is often intertwined with its social and material context. This event also raises questions about the future of such provocative works—whether they will continue to be seen as art or simply as luxury assets—and how the art market navigates the thin line between cultural critique and commercialism.
What the papers say
The articles from NY Post, AP News, and The Independent all emphasize Cattelan's reputation as a provocateur and the social commentary embedded in 'America.' The NY Post highlights the work's history, including its theft from Blenheim Palace and its previous display at the Guggenheim, where it drew over 100,000 visitors. AP News underscores the piece's dual nature as both art and functional object, noting Sotheby’s description of it as a commentary on the collision of artistic production and commodity value. The Independent focuses on the auction's significance, the piece's history of theft, and its satirical critique of wealth, emphasizing the work's intrinsic value due to its material and conceptual aspects. While all sources agree on the provocative nature and high valuation, the NY Post provides the most detailed account of the piece's history and upcoming display, making it the most comprehensive source for this story.
How we got here
Cattelan's 'America' was first created in 2016 as a satirical piece on wealth and value, with a version installed at the Guggenheim Museum. It was stolen from Blenheim Palace in 2019, never recovered, and likely melted down. The work has gained notoriety alongside other provocative pieces like the duct-taped banana 'Comedian.'
Go deeper
More on these topics
-
Maurizio Cattelan is an Italian visual artist. Known primarily for his hyperrealistic sculptures and installations, Cattelan's practice also includes curating and publishing.
-
Blenheim Palace ( BLEN-im) is a country house in Woodstock, Oxfordshire, England. It is the seat of the Dukes of Marlborough. Originally called Blenheim Castle, it has been known as Blenheim Palace since the 19th century. One of England's largest houses.