What's happened
Holtec International has abandoned its proposal to build a temporary nuclear waste storage facility in New Mexico, citing an 'untenable' path forward. The decision follows ongoing opposition and legal challenges, highlighting the broader impasse in the US over permanent nuclear waste disposal. The project was licensed in 2023 but faced resistance from state officials and environmental groups.
What's behind the headline?
Holtec's decision to withdraw from the New Mexico project underscores the entrenched political and environmental opposition to nuclear waste storage in the US. Despite regulatory approval, local resistance—particularly from New Mexico's governor and legislature—highlight the difficulty of advancing nuclear infrastructure without a clear, permanent solution. The Sierra Club's criticism that 'no one wants the waste' reveals a fundamental societal aversion to nuclear byproducts, which hampers progress. This impasse will likely prolong the US's reliance on aging storage sites, increasing risks and costs. The broader implication is that without a federal commitment to a permanent repository, temporary solutions will remain politically contentious and technically uncertain, delaying progress on nuclear waste management.
What the papers say
The Independent reports that Holtec described the 'untenable' path forward and withdrew despite a Supreme Court ruling that had temporarily revived storage plans. AP News confirms the decision and notes Holtec's intention to work with more receptive states, emphasizing ongoing opposition and the unresolved issue of nuclear waste. Both sources highlight the political resistance in New Mexico, with critics like the Sierra Club emphasizing societal rejection of nuclear waste. The coverage underscores the broader national gridlock over permanent disposal solutions, with environmental groups and state officials blocking progress despite regulatory approvals.
How we got here
The US faces a longstanding challenge in managing nuclear waste, with roughly 100,000 tons stored at nuclear sites nationwide. The proposed multibillion-dollar storage complex in New Mexico was licensed in 2023 but faced opposition from state authorities and environmental advocates, who argue that without a permanent repository, 'interim' storage is misleading. The Supreme Court's August ruling had temporarily revived plans for storage in Texas and New Mexico, but Holtec's withdrawal underscores the persistent political and environmental hurdles.
Go deeper
Common question
-
Why Did Holtec Withdraw from the NM Nuclear Storage Project?
Holtec International's decision to pull out of the New Mexico nuclear waste storage project has raised many questions. What led to this withdrawal, and what does it mean for nuclear waste management in the US? Below, we explore the main challenges facing nuclear waste disposal, possible alternatives, and the future of nuclear energy in the country.
-
What’s Next for Nuclear Waste Management in the US?
The recent withdrawal of Holtec from its proposed nuclear waste storage project in New Mexico highlights ongoing challenges in managing nuclear waste in the US. With political opposition, environmental concerns, and legal hurdles, many are asking what the future holds for nuclear waste disposal. In this page, we explore the next steps, the possibility of permanent storage, and the broader impact on energy policies and environmental safety.
More on these topics
-
Susana Martinez is an American politician and attorney who served as the 31st governor of New Mexico from 2011 to 2019. A Republican, she served as chair of the Republican Governors Association from 2015 to 2016.
-
Holtec International is a supplier of equipment and systems for the energy industry founded in Mount Laurel, New Jersey and based in Jupiter, Florida, United States. It specializes in the design and manufacture of parts for nuclear reactors. The company s
-
The Sierra Club is an environmental organization in the United States and in two U.S. Territories, namely Puerto Rico and Washington D.C.
-
Michelle Lynn Lujan Grisham is an American lawyer and politician who serves in the United States House of Representatives since 2013 and is the Governor-elect of New Mexico. She is a member of the Democratic Party.