What's happened
Hershey's plans to revert to using real milk and dark chocolate in all products by 2027, following criticism from the Reese family and consumer concerns over ingredient changes. The move affects less than 3% of products, with some reformulations already underway, but critics remain skeptical about the timeline.
What's behind the headline?
The announcement signals Hershey's attempt to address longstanding consumer and family concerns, but skepticism remains. The company’s plan to reformulate less than 3% of its products suggests a limited scope, likely aimed at appeasing critics without disrupting its broader portfolio. The delay until 2027 indicates a strategic move to balance ingredient sourcing, supply chain adjustments, and reformulation efforts. Brad Reese’s vocal opposition highlights ongoing tensions between legacy brand values and corporate cost-cutting, which could impact consumer trust. The decision to reformulate Kit Kat for a creamier taste and eliminate artificial dyes aligns with industry trends toward natural ingredients, but the real test will be whether Hershey’s can convincingly restore its reputation for quality and transparency. This story underscores the importance of brand authenticity in a competitive confectionery market, where consumer loyalty hinges on perceived ingredient integrity. The next steps will determine if Hershey’s can effectively rebuild trust or if the controversy will persist, affecting sales and brand image long-term.
What the papers say
The New York Times reports that Hershey's will return to using real chocolate in all products by 2027, following criticism from Brad Reese, who accused the company of lowering ingredient quality. The NY Post highlights that only a small percentage of products will be affected, but Reese remains skeptical, calling Hershey's claims a 'PR stunt.' The Independent notes Hershey's broader reformulation efforts, including natural colors and a creamier Kit Kat recipe, with increased R&D investment. The controversy stems from Reese family objections and consumer concerns over ingredient transparency, with some critics questioning Hershey’s sincerity given its delayed timeline and limited scope. These contrasting perspectives reveal a tension between corporate branding strategies and consumer trust, with critics demanding more immediate action and transparency.
How we got here
Hershey's has reformulated some of its products over recent years due to rising cocoa prices and consumer demand for natural ingredients. The company announced in 2026 that it will shift certain candies, like Reese’s mini cups and Easter eggs, back to real chocolate recipes in 2027. The controversy was sparked by Brad Reese, grandson of the original Reese’s creator, who publicly criticized Hershey’s for replacing real ingredients with cheaper substitutes, leading to a family feud and public debate about product quality and transparency.
Go deeper
More on these topics