What's happened
France's Macron is consolidating influence by appointing allies to top institutions, including the Cour des Comptes and Conseil Constitutionnel. Critics warn this risks politicising these bodies ahead of the 2027 presidential election, raising concerns over independence and Macron's legacy.
What's behind the headline?
Macron’s strategic appointments signal a deliberate effort to extend his influence beyond his presidential term. By placing allies like de Montchalin at the Cour des Comptes and Richard Ferrand at the Conseil Constitutionnel, Macron is effectively shaping the political landscape to favor his legacy. Critics argue this mirrors US-style politicisation of judicial and oversight bodies, risking the independence of France’s institutions. The timing—just ahead of the 2027 election—suggests these moves are designed to secure Macron’s long-term influence. The appointment of loyalists to roles like the Bank of France governor further consolidates this trend, raising questions about the balance of power and the health of French democracy. While Macron’s supporters see these as necessary for stability, opponents warn they threaten the core principle of institutional independence, potentially undermining public trust and the integrity of France’s political system. This pattern indicates Macron’s intent to embed his political allies into France’s foundational institutions, which could influence policy and oversight long after his presidency ends. The broader implication is a shift towards a more politicised governance model, with future presidents potentially facing a landscape heavily shaped by Macron’s appointments, diminishing institutional neutrality and independence.
What the papers say
The articles from Politico and France 24 highlight contrasting perspectives on Macron’s appointments. Politico emphasizes the strategic nature of Macron’s influence, noting that placing loyalists like de Montchalin and Ferrand in key roles could undermine institutional independence, comparing this trend to US politicisation. Joanna York of France 24 underscores the controversy, with critics accusing Macron of manoeuvring to secure his legacy and weaken France’s democratic checks. The debate centers on whether these appointments are necessary stabilisers or threats to France’s institutional integrity, with some experts warning of a dangerous trend towards politicisation that could impact France’s democracy for years to come.
How we got here
Recent appointments by President Macron, including the head of the Cour des Comptes and the Conseil Constitutionnel, have sparked controversy. Critics argue these moves aim to strengthen Macron’s influence over France’s key institutions as his term nears its end, amid fears of politicisation and undermining independence. The appointments follow Macron’s pattern of placing loyalists in influential roles, raising concerns about the future of France’s institutional independence and the potential impact on the upcoming presidential election.
Go deeper
More on these topics