What's happened
A 2025 film starring Russell Crowe depicts Hermann Göring's interactions with psychiatrist Douglas Kelley during the Nuremberg trials. Based on a 2013 book, it offers a realistic portrayal of the Nazi leader and the psychological analysis of war criminals, highlighting themes of humanity and evil.
What's behind the headline?
The film's focus on Kelley’s relationship with Göring humanizes a historically dehumanized figure, challenging viewers to reconsider the 'banality of evil.' It underscores how even monsters like Göring can display human traits, complicating moral judgments. The movie also highlights the importance of psychological evaluation in justice, suggesting that understanding the minds of war criminals is crucial for historical accountability. However, critics note that the characters often feel like archetypes rather than fully fleshed-out individuals, which may diminish emotional engagement. The film’s timing is significant, as it prompts reflection on the ongoing relevance of justice, morality, and the psychology of evil in contemporary society. It forecasts a continued interest in exploring the moral complexities of history, with potential implications for how future tribunals and psychological assessments are conducted.
What the papers say
The Times of Israel emphasizes the film’s attempt to take a more realistic approach to the Nuremberg story, contrasting it with the 1961 epic 'Judgement at Nuremberg.' It highlights Crowe’s portrayal of Göring and Malek’s role as Kelley, noting the film’s focus on humanizing Nazi figures. The NY Post discusses Malek’s insights into Kelley’s ambition and narcissism, as well as the intense filming scenes. AP News provides context on Kelley’s life, his work evaluating Nazi officials, and his tragic end, drawing parallels with Göring’s suicide. The Independent reviews the film’s thematic exploration of morality and evil, criticizing character development but acknowledging its relevance. Overall, the sources agree that the film offers a thought-provoking, if somewhat stylized, depiction of a pivotal moment in history, emphasizing the psychological and moral questions surrounding justice after WWII.
How we got here
The film is based on the 2013 book 'The Nazi and the Psychiatrist' by Jack El-Hai, which explores the life of Douglas Kelley, the psychiatrist who evaluated Nazi officials after WWII. Kelley’s own life ended in suicide, echoing Hermann Göring’s death in prison. The story examines the psychological profiles of Nazi leaders and the early debates about justice and morality after the war.
Go deeper
More on these topics
-
Rami Said Malek is an American actor. He is best known for portraying computer hacker Elliot Alderson in the USA Network television series Mr.
-
Hermann Wilhelm Göring was a German politician, military leader and convicted war criminal. He was one of the most powerful figures in the Nazi Party, which ruled Germany from 1933 to 1945.
-
Russell Ira Crowe is an actor, film producer, director and musician. Although a New Zealand citizen, he has lived most of his life in Australia.
-
James Platten Vanderbilt is an American screenwriter and film producer best known for the films Zodiac, White House Down, The Amazing Spider-Man, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 and Murder Mystery.