What's happened
Alaska's governor claims high crime rates in Anchorage, citing over half of state murders and robberies. The police chief counters, describing the issue as complex. Crime trends across US cities show a significant decline in 2025, with violent crime below pre-pandemic levels for the first time in years.
What's behind the headline?
The current discourse reveals a disconnect between local political narratives and broader crime trends. While Anchorage's leadership emphasizes the city's high crime figures, police officials highlight the complexity and variability of crime data. The nationwide decline in violent crime suggests that the recent surge was likely a pandemic-related anomaly rather than a new normal. This decline is driven by multiple factors, including social, economic, and policy changes, which are not solely attributable to law enforcement efforts. The political debate may be influenced by local interests or attempts to shape public perception, but the data indicates a broader trend of decreasing violence. Future policy should consider these macro trends, focusing on sustainable solutions rather than reactive measures based on selective data. The decline in crime also challenges traditional assumptions about the causes of violence, suggesting that broad social forces play a significant role, and that localized efforts alone may be insufficient to address the root causes.
What the papers say
The AP News article highlights Anchorage's political dispute over crime statistics, with the governor emphasizing the city's high crime rates and police chief Sean Case describing the issue as complex. Meanwhile, the New York Times and AP News reports detail a nationwide trend of declining violent crime in 2025, with the Council on Criminal Justice noting that all seven tracked categories fell below pre-pandemic levels for the first time in years. Experts like Adam Gelb and Jens Ludwig point to broad social and economic factors influencing these trends, challenging the notion that localized policies are the sole drivers of crime rates. The contrasting narratives reflect a tension between local political agendas and empirical data showing a significant national decline.
How we got here
The debate over crime in Anchorage stems from the governor's characterization of the city as having a high crime rate, contrasted by police officials who describe the issue as complex. Nationally, crime rates surged during the COVID-19 pandemic but have since declined sharply, with 2025 marking the first year all tracked violent crime categories fell below pre-pandemic levels.
Go deeper
Common question
-
Why Are Violent Crimes Dropping in the US?
Recent data shows a significant decline in violent crime rates across the United States, reaching levels not seen in decades. This trend raises many questions: what's causing this drop? Is it consistent everywhere? Could it last? In this page, we'll explore the key factors behind the decline, what it means for the future, and answer the most common questions about this important shift in crime trends.
-
Is Crime Really at a Decades-Low Level in the US?
Recent data shows a significant drop in violent crimes across the US, sparking questions about whether crime rates are truly at their lowest in decades. Many wonder what factors are driving this decline and what it means for public safety. In this page, we explore the latest crime trends, the categories most affected, and what the future might hold for crime and safety in America.
-
Is Crime Really Rising in Alaska or Is It Just Politics?
Alaska's crime debate has been heating up, with claims of rising crime rates in Anchorage sparking national attention. While some officials highlight high murder and robbery figures, others point to broader social trends and declining crime nationwide. Curious about what's really happening? Below, we explore the facts, compare Alaska to other US cities, and look at the bigger picture of crime trends across America.
More on these topics