What's happened
During King Charles' visit to Canberra, Senator Lidia Thorpe interrupted the royal reception, accusing him of genocide against Indigenous Australians. Her protest has sparked significant backlash from politicians and Indigenous leaders, who criticized her approach as disrespectful and ineffective.
Go deeper
Impact of the Protest
- Public Reaction: Thorpe's actions have polarized opinions, with some viewing her as a voice for Indigenous rights while others see her as disrespectful.
- Political Consequences: The backlash from both sides of parliament may hinder future discussions on Indigenous issues, as it shifts focus from the message to the method.
- Indigenous Representation: Aunty Violet Sheridan, a Ngunnawal elder, stated that Thorpe does not represent all Indigenous voices, highlighting the diversity of opinions within First Nations communities.
Future Implications
- Ongoing Dialogue: Thorpe's protest may prompt further discussions about the monarchy's role in Australia, but it risks alienating potential allies in the reconciliation process.
- Calls for Treaty: The demand for a treaty and acknowledgment of historical injustices remains a critical issue, with Thorpe's actions bringing it back into the spotlight, albeit controversially.
What the papers say
According to Sarah Collard from The Guardian, Aunty Violet Sheridan criticized Thorpe's outburst as 'disrespectful' and stated, 'Lidia Thorpe does not speak for me and my people.' This sentiment reflects a divide among Indigenous leaders regarding the best approach to advocate for rights. In contrast, SBS reported Thorpe's defense, claiming her protest was necessary after her requests for dialogue were ignored. This highlights the tension between traditional forms of engagement and more confrontational tactics in the fight for Indigenous rights. The differing perspectives underscore the complexity of the issue and the varied strategies employed by Indigenous advocates.
How we got here
Senator Lidia Thorpe's protest comes amid ongoing discussions about Indigenous rights and sovereignty in Australia. Her actions reflect a broader discontent with the monarchy's historical role in colonization and the treatment of First Nations peoples.
More on these topics
-
Charles, Prince of Wales is the heir apparent to the British throne as the eldest child of Queen Elizabeth II. He has been Duke of Cornwall and Duke of Rothesay since 1952, and he is the oldest and longest-serving heir apparent in British history.