What's happened
Recent law enforcement training drills, notably a four-on-one exercise at the Texas Game Warden Training Center, have resulted in at least 13 injuries and one death since 2005. Critics argue these drills pose significant physical and mental risks, despite official investigations finding no wrongdoing.
What's behind the headline?
The four-on-one drill at the Texas Game Warden Training Center exemplifies the risks inherent in law enforcement training. Despite its intent to simulate real-world stress, the exercise's design—where recruits face multiple attackers without the ability to defend themselves—has led to serious injuries, including concussions and broken bones. Critics argue that such scenarios are excessively brutal and lack proper safety oversight, especially given the absence of national safety standards or medical personnel on site. The repeated pattern of injuries and deaths nationwide suggests that these drills, while aimed at critical skill development, often cross the line into physical and psychological abuse. Law enforcement experts acknowledge the value of realistic training but warn that poorly supervised exercises can deter promising recruits and cause lasting harm. The recent incidents underscore the urgent need for standardized safety protocols and a reassessment of training practices to balance realism with safety, ensuring that officers are prepared without risking their lives.
What the papers say
The Independent reports that at least 13 cadets were injured during a 2024 Texas drill, with some requiring surgery, and highlights concerns from participants like Heather Sterling, a former Wyoming game warden, who described the exercise as a 'poorly disguised assault.' AP News emphasizes that similar drills nationwide have been linked to at least a dozen deaths and hundreds of injuries since 2005, including a recent case where a recruit died after fighting an instructor in Kentucky. Both sources note the lack of uniform safety standards and the ongoing debate over the appropriateness of such intense exercises, with critics warning they may do more harm than good. The Independent also details Sterling's experience, where she was punched multiple times and suffered a concussion, leading her to resign in protest and speak out for reform. The AP articles contextualize these incidents within a broader pattern of dangerous training environments, raising questions about the necessity and safety of these high-stress drills.
How we got here
Since 2005, law enforcement academies across the US have used intense defensive tactics drills, often called RedMan training, to prepare recruits for high-stress encounters. These exercises aim to teach self-defense but have been linked to numerous injuries and fatalities, raising concerns about safety standards and oversight. Recent incidents, including a 2024 Texas drill, highlight ongoing risks and debates over training methods.
Go deeper
Common question
-
Are Law Enforcement Drills Safe? What You Need to Know
Recent law enforcement training exercises, especially the four-on-one drills, have raised serious questions about safety and risks. With reports of injuries and fatalities linked to these exercises, many are wondering how safe these drills really are and what measures are in place to protect participants. In this page, we explore the dangers, recent incidents, and ongoing safety reviews surrounding law enforcement training practices.
-
Are Current Law Enforcement Drills Safe?
Recent incidents involving law enforcement training exercises have raised serious questions about safety standards and their impact on community safety. With reports of injuries and fatalities linked to high-stress drills like the four-on-one exercise, many are asking whether these practices are too risky. In this page, we explore the safety concerns, proposed reforms, and recent incidents to help you understand the ongoing debate around police training methods.
More on these topics