What's happened
The live-action Moana remake has drawn sharp criticism from Independent and Guardian reviewers who label it cynical and copy‑paste. Johnson’s return as Maui is described as stiff, with debate over whether the film adds anything new beyond the animated original.
What's behind the headline?
Analysis
- The reviews portray a film that mirrors its animated predecessor, raising questions about originality in big-budget remakes.
- Critics point to Johnson’s autopilot performance as a key flaw, suggesting the remake fails to exploit live-action possibilities.
- Audience reception may hinge on whether viewers value nostalgia over new cinematic risks.
- The piece forecasts continued debate about the viability of reimagining animated classics as live-action features.
Quote: Independent describes it as a "copy-and-paste" redo; Guardian notes a competent but pointless back-to-basics approach.
Implications
- If the pattern holds, studios may be discouraged from future live-action remakes of beloved animated properties.
How we got here
Disney has pressed ahead with a live-action Moana that reuses much of the 2016 animation’s material. Critics argue that the film relies on familiar beats and visual effects rather than fresh storytelling, with attention turning to Dwayne Johnson’s performance as Maui and Catherine Laga’aia’s portrayal of Moana.
Our analysis
Independent: reviews deem Moana remake a failure to innovate; Guardian: calls it a pointless back-to-basics film. The Times: notes Johnson’s performance as uneven; Guardian Australia: cites visual effects overshadowing story.
Go deeper
- Will audiences embrace or reject more live-action reimaginings of animated hits?
- How will Johnson adapt his performance in potential future projects?
- What does this mean for Disney’s live-action strategy?
More on these topics
-
Dwayne Johnson - Actor
Dwayne Douglas Johnson, also known by his ring name the Rock, is an American-Canadian actor, producer, businessman, retired professional wrestler, and former American football player.
-
Moana - 2016 animated film directed by John Musker and Ron Clements
Moana is a 2016 American animated musical adventure film produced by Walt Disney Animation Studios and directed by John Musker and Ron Clements from a screenplay by Jared Bush. The film stars Dwayne Johnson and Auliʻi Cravalho in her feature film debut. Its songs were written by Lin-Manuel Miranda, Opetaia Foaʻi, and Mark Mancina, who also composed the score. Set in ancient Polynesia, the film follows Moana, the strong-willed daughter of a village chief, who is chosen by the ocean to restore a mystical relic to the goddess Te Fiti. When a blight threatens her island, she sets sail in search of Maui, a legendary demigod, in hopes of saving her people. The screenplay draws inspiration from Polynesian mythology. Moana premiered at the AFI Fest at the El Capitan Theatre in Los Angeles on November 14, 2016, and was released theatrically in the United States on November 23. The film received positive reviews from critics and was a commercial success, grossing $687 million worldwide. At the 89th Academy Awards, it received nominations for Best Animated Feature and Best Original Song for "How Far I'll Go". The film later became a major streaming success on Disney+, ranking among the most-watched...
-
Jared Bush - American screenwriter
Jared Bush (born June 12, 1974) is an American screenwriter, producer, and director, best known for co-directing and co-writing the Disney animated film Zootopia in 2016, writing the Disney animated film Moana in the same year and co-creating and executiv
-
Thomas Kail - American theatre director
Thomas Kail is an American theatre director, known for directing the Off-Broadway and Broadway productions of Lin-Manuel Miranda's musicals In the Heights and Hamilton, garnering the 2016 Tony Award for Best Direction of a Musical for the latter.
-
Lin-Manuel Miranda - American composer
Lin-Manuel Miranda is an American composer, lyricist, actor, singer, rapper, producer, and playwright. He created and starred in the Broadway musicals In the Heights and Hamilton.
-
Jemaine Clement - New Zealand actor
Jemaine Clement is a New Zealand actor, musician, comedian, singer, director and writer. With Bret McKenzie, as the Grammy Award-winning comedy duo Flight of the Conchords, he has released several albums and created comedy series for both the BBC and HBO.