What's happened
Disney's ongoing dispute with YouTube TV has led to a blackout affecting millions, while its ratings and profits decline amid contract disputes and shifting viewer habits. The company reports mixed financial results, highlighting challenges in its traditional and streaming divisions as negotiations drag on.
What's behind the headline?
The Disney-YouTube TV dispute exemplifies the shifting landscape of media distribution, where traditional broadcasters face mounting pressure from streaming platforms and tech giants. Disney's blackout of ABC and ESPN on YouTube TV highlights the power struggle over carriage fees, with Disney demanding higher rates while YouTube pushes back, citing market dominance. This standoff reveals how content owners are increasingly willing to risk revenue to assert control over distribution terms. The financial impact is significant: analysts estimate Disney is losing $30 million weekly, and the blackout is its longest-ever carriage dispute. Meanwhile, Disney's mixed earnings reflect a broader industry trend—streaming revenue is growing, but traditional TV profits are shrinking due to declining viewership and rising sports rights costs. The controversy over Jimmy Kimmel also illustrates how internal programming decisions can ripple into subscriber behavior, further complicating Disney's strategic positioning. Looking ahead, Disney's ability to navigate these disputes and adapt to a fragmented media environment will determine its future profitability and market relevance.
What the papers say
The articles from NY Post, Business Insider UK, AP News, and The Independent collectively highlight Disney's current struggles with distribution disputes, declining traditional TV ratings, and financial pressures. The NY Post emphasizes the ratings decline and financial impact of the YouTube TV blackout, quoting Disney CFO Hugh Johnston on the ongoing negotiations. Business Insider UK notes Disney's disclosure in its 10-K about the dispute, estimating weekly losses and potential risks to programming rights. AP News reports Disney's earnings and the ongoing efforts to resolve licensing issues, while The Independent echoes these points, adding context about subscriber cancellations linked to programming controversies. The contrasting perspectives underscore the complexity of Disney's current challenges—balancing streaming growth with traditional media declines, all amid a tense negotiation environment with tech platforms.
How we got here
Disney's recent earnings reveal a complex picture: while streaming revenue grows, traditional TV profits decline sharply. The blackout of ABC and ESPN on YouTube TV began October 30, after contract negotiations failed, costing Disney an estimated $30 million weekly. The dispute underscores broader tensions over carriage fees and market power, amid a shrinking linear TV audience and rising costs for sports rights. Disney's financial results show a dip in revenue and profits, with streaming and linear TV divisions facing distinct pressures. The company is also navigating controversies around its programming, notably the temporary cancellation of Jimmy Kimmel Live!, which impacted subscriber cancellations. Despite these challenges, Disney remains committed to strategic share buybacks and dividend increases, aiming for double-digit earnings growth in 2026 and 2027.
Go deeper
More on these topics
-
The Walt Disney Company, commonly known as Disney, is an American diversified multinational mass media and entertainment conglomerate headquartered at the Walt Disney Studios complex in Burbank, California.
-
Robert Alan Iger (; born February 10, 1951) is an American media executive who is chief executive officer (CEO) of the Walt Disney Company. He previously was the president of the American Broadcasting Company (ABC) between 1994 and 1995 and president...
-
YouTube TV is an American streaming television service that offers live TV, on demand video and cloud-based DVR from more than 85 television networks. It is owned by YouTube, a subsidiary of Google, itself a subsidiary of Alphabet Inc.