What's happened
The childhood friends from England behind the Broadway musical nominated for eight Tony Awards relied on NYC films for inspiration. They recount watching romcoms nightly to shape the show’s tone and used local input to capture authentic New York life.
What's behind the headline?
Insightful context
- The creators have deepened the show’s authenticity by consulting New Yorkers and adjusting lines that felt inauthentic to local sensibilities.
- Their approach acknowledges that many popular NYC-set films depict a narrow slice of the city, which they consciously critique in the musical’s framing.
- The reliance on film as primary inspiration contrasts with the lived experience of the city, offering a self-aware commentary on representation in theatre.
Likely outcomes
- The show’s eight Tony nominations position it as a strong contender for Best Musical and Best Book.
- If the production continues to engage real New Yorkers in refinements, it may sustain audience interest through the Tony season and beyond.
How we got here
Buchan and Barne, who hail from England, created a musical about a British tourist in New York City. The show, which began in London in 2023 and moved to Broadway in 2024, is nominated for eight Tony Awards. They have incorporated input from actual New Yorkers and staff to refine dialogue and cultural details.
Our analysis
New York Post, Angela Barbuti, May 31, 2026; Guardian, Rosanna Greenstreet, May 30, 2026; Guardian, Rosanna Greenstreet, May 23, 2026
Go deeper
- Will the show’s reliance on classic NYC films affect its long-term relevance?
- How are local voices shaping future revisions to the script?
- Which moments benefited most from New Yorker feedback?
More on these topics
-
The Guardian - Newspaper
The Guardian is a British daily newspaper. It was founded in 1821 as The Manchester Guardian, and changed its name in 1959. Along with its sister papers The Observer and The Guardian Weekly, The Guardian is part of the Guardian Media Group, owned by the S