What's happened
John Swinney will delay a decision on splitting Scotland’s Lord Advocate roles until after May’s election, citing ongoing research and the need for thorough debate amid controversy over the current dual role and recent legal cases involving SNP figures.
What's behind the headline?
The delay in publishing the McMillan report underscores the political sensitivity surrounding the Lord Advocate’s dual role. The Scottish government’s reluctance to act reflects a broader tension between maintaining political influence and ensuring prosecutorial independence. The recent cases involving SNP figures, especially Murrell, highlight perceived conflicts of interest that undermine public trust. The comparison with England and Wales, where roles are separated, suggests reform is both feasible and necessary. The current situation risks further erosion of confidence in Scotland’s legal system, and the next parliament will likely face pressure to implement structural changes to safeguard judicial impartiality. This controversy reveals how intertwined politics and law remain in Scotland, with the potential for long-term constitutional implications if reforms are not pursued.
What the papers say
The Scotsman reports that John Swinney is delaying a decision on the Lord Advocate role split, citing ongoing research and parliamentary time constraints, with the publication of Malcolm McMillan’s report expected after the election. The Guardian highlights the controversy over Dorothy Bain’s handling of SNP-related cases, emphasizing concerns about conflicts of interest and transparency. Both articles reveal a political landscape hesitant to reform, despite longstanding calls from legal experts and opposition parties. The delay appears to be driven by political caution rather than legal complexity, with critics warning that the current dual role compromises judicial independence and fuels public distrust. The debate is set to continue into the next parliamentary session, with reform advocates arguing that separation of powers will strengthen Scotland’s legal integrity.
How we got here
The debate over the Lord Advocate’s dual role as Scotland’s chief prosecutor and legal adviser has persisted for years, with calls for separation growing since 2007. A report by Malcolm McMillan, commissioned to examine this, has faced delays despite being peer-reviewed last summer. The controversy intensified following cases involving SNP figures, notably Peter Murrell, and questions over transparency and independence in legal proceedings. The SNP’s 2021 manifesto promised a consultation on reform, but no action has yet been taken, fueling criticism from opposition parties and legal experts.
Go deeper
More on these topics
-
Peter Tierney Murrell is the Chief Executive Officer of the Scottish National Party. He is married to Nicola Sturgeon, the party's leader and First Minister of Scotland.
-
John Ramsay Swinney is a Scottish politician serving as Deputy First Minister of Scotland since 2014 and Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills since 2016.
-
Dorothy Ruth Bain QC is a Scottish advocate who has served as Lord Advocate since 2021. She previously served as the Principal Advocate Depute from 2009 to 2011, becoming the first and highest-ranking female to hold the prosecutorial position in Scotland.
-
Liam Kerr is a Scottish Conservative Party politician who served as Deputy Leader of the Scottish Conservative Party from 2019 to 2020 and as the Scottish Conservatives’ Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Justice from 2017 to 2021.
-
Angela Constance is a Scottish National Party politician who served as Cabinet Secretary for Communities, Social Security and Equalities from May 2016 to June 2018.