What's happened
VAR ruled Haaland onside for Manchester City’s 1-0 win over United before Pro Ref acknowledged an error of judgement. Officials will not officiate next fixtures after the international break as investigations begin. Carrick and Maresca have defended their positions amid renewed scrutiny of officiating and offside technology.
What's behind the headline?
Key issues
- VAR’s handling of Enzo Fernandez’s position has become a central talking point, prompting calls for transparency and potential changes in how offside influence is assessed.
- Howard Webb has admitted an error of judgement and will review the process; this may lead to revised protocols or stricter guidelines for on-field reviews.
- City’s and United’s managers are facing scrutiny over post-match comments; the dynamic underscores how officiating decisions can impact reputations and future fixtures.
What this means for fans
- Expect closer scrutiny of VAR decisions in upcoming fixtures, with potential adjustments to how offside influence is evaluated.
- The incident could influence conversations on rule clarity and implementation in the Premier League.
How we got here
Manchester United and Manchester City faced off in a 1-0 derby in which Haaland’s 60th-minute goal was initially ruled offside. VAR later adjudged Haaland onside, but Enzo Fernandez’s offside influence was not recognised, triggering Pro Ref’s admission of an error and setting the stage for a review of refereeing standards.
Our analysis
- BBC Business: Pro Ref acknowledges error in Haaland offside decision; Webb notes disappointment and promises review. - Independent: Maresca and Carrick comment on the incident; VAR officials face scrutiny. - Guardian: Pro Ref sets out the incident and implications for upcoming fixtures.
Go deeper
- Will the Premier League change offside rules or VAR procedures after this incident?
- Which officials are at risk of sanctions or replacement after the review?
- How will clubs prepare for future derbies given the ongoing controversy?
More on these topics
-
Erling Haaland - Norwegian footballer
Erling Braut Haaland is a Norwegian professional footballer who plays as a striker for Bundesliga club Borussia Dortmund and the Norway national team.
-
Premier League - Football league
The Premier League, often referred to as the English Premier League or the EPL outside England, is the top level of the English football league system.
-
Old Trafford - Stadium in Stretford, England
Old Trafford is a football stadium in Old Trafford, Greater Manchester, England, and the home of Manchester United. With a capacity of 74,879, it is the largest club football stadium in the United Kingdom, and the eleventh-largest in Europe.
-
Phil Foden - Footballer
Philip Walter Foden is an English professional footballer who plays as a midfielder for Premier League club Manchester City and the England under-21 team.
-
Howard Webb - Football referee
Howard Melton Webb, MBE is an English former professional football referee who officiated primarily in the Premier League from 2003 to 2014, as well as for FIFA as a FIFA international referee from 2005 to 2014.
-
Manchester City Football Club - Football club
Manchester City Football Club is an English football club based in Manchester that competes in the Premier League, the top flight of English football. Founded in 1880 as St. Mark's, it became Ardwick Association Football Club in 1887 and Manchester City i
-
Bruno Fernandes - Portuguese footballer
Bruno Miguel Borges Fernandes is a Portuguese professional footballer who plays as a midfielder for Premier League club Manchester United and the Portugal national team.
-
Manchester United F.C. - Football club
Manchester United Football Club is a professional football club based in Old Trafford, Greater Manchester, England, that competes in the Premier League, the top flight of English football.
-
Michael Carrick - English football player
Michael Carrick is an English professional football coach and former player who is currently working as a first-team coach at Manchester United.
-
Norwich City Football Club - Football club
Norwich City Football Club is an English professional football club based in Norwich, Norfolk, that competes in the Championship, the second division of English football. The club was founded in 1902.
-
British Broadcasting Corporation - Broadcasting company
The British Broadcasting Corporation is a British public service broadcaster. Headquartered at Broadcasting House in Westminster, London, it is the world's oldest national broadcaster, and the largest broadcaster in the world by number of employees.
-
Enzo Maresca - Italian former footballer
Vincenzo 'Enzo' Maresca is an Italian former footballer who played as a midfielder, and is the current Parma manager. After starting out at West Bromwich Albion in 1998, he went on to play for several clubs in his country, including Juventus, who loaned h
-
Lisandro Martínez - Argentine footballer
Lisandro Martínez is an Argentine professional footballer who plays as a centre-back for Eredivisie club Ajax and the Argentina national team.
-
Fulham F.C. - Association football club in London, England
Fulham Football Club is a professional football club based in West London, England. The club competes in the Premier League, the top tier of English football. Founded in 1879, they have played home games at Craven Cottage since 1896. Fulham contest West London derby rivalries with Chelsea, Brentford and Queens Park Rangers. The club adopted a white shirt and black shorts as its kit in 1896, which has been used ever since. Founded in 1879, they are London's second oldest professional football club after Crystal Palace, who were founded in 1861. They joined the Southern League in 1898 and won two First Division titles (1905–06 and 1906–07), as well as two Second Division titles and a Western League title. Elected into the Second Division of the Football League in 1907, Fulham would win the Third Division South in 1931–32, four years after being relegated. They won the Second Division title in 1948–49, though were relegated after three seasons. Promoted back to the First Division again in 1958–59, the form of star player Johnny Haynes helped Fulham to remain in the top-flight until consecutive relegations occurred by 1969. They were promoted in 1970–71 and went on to reach the final of...
-
Wayne Rooney - English footballer and manager
Wayne Mark Rooney (born 24 October 1985) is an English professional football manager and former player who was most recently the head coach of EFL Championship club Plymouth Argyle. Widely considered one of the best players of his generation and one...
-
Marcus Rashford - Footballer
Marcus Rashford is an English professional footballer who plays as a forward for Premier League club Manchester United and the England national team.
-
Enzo Fernández - French former footballer
Enzo Alan Zidane, known simply as Enzo, is a French former professional footballer who played as a midfielder. Zidane is a youth product of Real Madrid, where he scored on his only first-team appearance in the Copa del Rey in 2016.