What's happened
Israel is debating a revised conscription bill aimed at increasing Haredi military service while maintaining exemptions for yeshiva students. The bill faces opposition from coalition members, legal advisers, and opposition parties amid ongoing political and security tensions. The debate underscores deep divisions over military service and ultra-Orthodox exemptions.
What's behind the headline?
The proposed legislation reveals a strategic political maneuver rather than a genuine effort to increase military enlistment. While it claims to regulate yeshiva students' status, the bill's provisions are designed to preserve exemptions and avoid meaningful sanctions. The broad definition of 'Haredi' allows many who are no longer observant to be counted, undermining the bill's stated goals. The political motivation is clear: Netanyahu's government seeks to appease ultra-Orthodox parties to maintain coalition stability, even at the expense of national security. The bill's weak sanctions and vague enforcement mechanisms suggest it will do little to address the IDF's manpower shortages. The opposition, including former officials and military leaders, argue that the bill is a political bluff that will not lead to real change, risking further erosion of public trust and security. The ongoing internal coalition conflicts and legal challenges indicate that the legislation's future remains uncertain, and its passage may ultimately be blocked by the courts or opposition.
What the papers say
The Times of Israel provides detailed coverage of the legislative process, highlighting internal coalition disputes and legal concerns. The articles emphasize the political motivations behind the bill, with critics arguing it is a superficial measure aimed at political gain rather than security. France 24 and The New Arab contextualize the issue within Israel's broader societal and security challenges, noting the historical exemptions for ultra-Orthodox men and the mounting pressure from military needs. Both sources underscore the deep societal divisions and the influence of ultra-Orthodox parties on Israeli politics, with France 24 emphasizing the recent arrests of draft evaders and the ongoing resistance within the community. The contrasting opinions from former officials and opposition leaders, such as Yair Lapid and Naftali Bennett, highlight the broad consensus that the bill is more political theater than effective policy.
How we got here
The debate over Haredi military exemptions dates back to Israel's founding, with full-time Torah study men historically exempted from service. Recent court rulings declared blanket exemptions illegal, prompting the government to draft legislation balancing security needs with religious freedoms. The ultra-Orthodox community's opposition to conscription and political influence has shaped the legislative process, leading to multiple drafts and internal disagreements.
Go deeper
Common question
-
What is the new draft bill in Israel about?
Israel's proposed military draft law has sparked widespread debate, especially regarding exemptions for ultra-Orthodox communities. Many wonder what changes are being proposed, why they matter, and how they could impact the country's stability and security. Below, we explore the key questions surrounding this controversial legislation and what it means for Israel's future.
-
What Do Recent Events Say About US Security and Global Stability?
Recent headlines highlight significant developments in US security, international politics, and health research. From a deadly attack near the White House to debates over military service in Israel and setbacks in Alzheimer's drug trials, these stories raise important questions about national safety, policy responses, and future implications. Here, we explore what these events mean for everyday citizens and how governments are reacting to new threats and challenges.
-
What Do Recent News Developments Mean for the Future of Medicine and Politics?
Recent headlines highlight significant shifts in medical research and political stability worldwide. From the challenges of Alzheimer’s drug trials to debates over military service laws, these stories raise important questions about the future. What do these developments mean for innovation, health, and security? Below, we explore the key questions and what they could mean for you.
More on these topics
-
Benjamin Netanyahu is an Israeli politician serving as Prime Minister of Israel since 2009, and previously from 1996 to 1999. Netanyahu is also the Chairman of the Likud – National Liberal Movement.
-
Boaz Bismuth (Hebrew pronunciation: [bismut], Hebrew: בועז ביסמוט; born 25 November 1964) is a member of the Israeli Knesset, the head of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, a journalist and columnist who served as editor-in-chief of Isra
-
Yuli-Yoel Edelstein is an Israeli politician serving as Minister of Health since 2020. One of the most prominent refuseniks in the Soviet Union, he was the 16th Speaker of the Knesset from 2013 until his resignation on 25 March 2020.
-
Yair Lapid is an Israeli politician and former journalist serving as chairman of the Yesh Atid party and opposition leader in the Knesset. He served as Minister of Finance from 2013 to 2014. Before entering politics in 2012, Lapid was an author, TV presen
-
Naftali Bennett is an Israeli politician who led the Jewish Home party between 2012 and 2018 and currently serves as an MK for New Right.
-
Likud, officially the Likud – National Liberal Movement, is a centre-right to right-wing political party in Israel. A secular party, it was founded in 1973 by Menachem Begin and Ariel Sharon in an alliance with several right-wing parties.
-
United Torah Judaism, often referred to by its electoral symbol Gimel, is a religious conservative political alliance in Israel.
-
Shas is a Haredi religious political party in Israel. Founded in 1984 under the leadership of Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, a former Israeli Sephardi chief rabbi, who remained its spiritual leader until his death in October 2013, it primarily represents the interes
-
Dan Eliyahu Ya'akov Illouz (Hebrew: דן אליהו יעקב אילוז) (born 23 February 1986) is a Canadian-born Israeli politician currently serving as a member of the Knesset for the Likud party since January 2023. He was previously a city councillor