What's happened
New York City plans to dismantle its gifted and talented (G&T) programs, citing equity concerns. Critics argue this will reduce opportunities for high-achieving students, especially from low- and middle-income families, and could worsen public school enrollment declines amid dissatisfaction with curriculum rigor.
What's behind the headline?
The proposed elimination of NYC's gifted programs reflects a contentious debate over educational equity versus excellence. Critics argue that removing advanced seats will disproportionately harm high-potential students from lower-income backgrounds, who lack access to private tutoring or specialized private schools. Research shows ability grouping benefits high-achievers without harming others, and NYC's own studies indicate significant gains for Black and Hispanic students in G&T programs. Eliminating these programs risks widening educational disparities and accelerating public school decline, which already sees an 8% drop in enrollment since 2020. Conversely, proponents claim the move promotes fairness, but evidence suggests that denying opportunities for accelerated learning undermines social mobility and the city's competitiveness. The decision appears driven by a desire to address equity, but it may inadvertently deepen inequality and weaken the public education system's appeal, especially for progressive families and immigrant communities who value high standards.
What the papers say
The New York Post highlights the potential negative impact on public school enrollment and criticizes the move as a setback for social mobility, emphasizing that wealthy families will still access private options. The Post Editorial Board underscores the inconsistency of the policy with previous expansion efforts and criticizes the move as a betrayal of educational opportunity. Meanwhile, The Mirror reports concerns from the National Education Union about rising racism, social media impacts, and the importance of investing in mental health, providing a broader context of challenges facing UK education, which, while not directly related, underscores the global importance of equitable and well-resourced education systems. The articles collectively suggest that dismantling gifted programs may undermine efforts to promote fairness and excellence in education, risking increased inequality and public dissatisfaction.
How we got here
NYC's G&T programs have historically identified gifted students through standardized testing and teacher referrals. Since 2021, the city has expanded these identifications from 3,500 to nearly 10,000 children annually, but only 2,500 seats are available. The move to eliminate these programs aligns with broader debates over educational equity and resource allocation, amid ongoing public dissatisfaction and declining enrollment in public schools.
Go deeper
Common question
-
Why is NYC ending gifted programs? What does this mean for students and families?
New York City’s decision to dismantle its gifted and talented (G&T) programs has sparked widespread debate. Many wonder why this move is happening, how it will impact high-achieving students, and what it says about education equity today. Below, we explore the reasons behind this change, the arguments for and against it, and what families need to know about the future of gifted education in NYC.
-
Why Is NYC Ending Its Gifted and Talented Programs?
New York City is planning to dismantle its gifted and talented (G&T) programs, citing concerns about equity and fairness. This move raises many questions about what it means for high-achieving students, school diversity, and future educational opportunities. If you're wondering why this change is happening and how it might affect students, read on to find clear answers to your most pressing questions.
-
What Are the Biggest Global Conflicts Right Now?
With tensions rising worldwide, understanding the key conflicts and their implications is more important than ever. From trade wars to regional disputes, these issues shape our daily lives and the future of international stability. Below, explore the most pressing conflicts happening today and what they mean for you.
More on these topics
-
Bill de Blasio is an American politician who since 2014 has served as the 109th Mayor of New York City. Prior to his first election to the position of Mayor, he served as New York City's public advocate from 2010 to 2013.
-
New York is a state in the Northeastern United States. New York was one of the original thirteen colonies that formed the United States. With more than 19 million residents in 2019, it is the fourth-most-populous state.