What's happened
Seamus Culleton, an Irish national living in the US for nearly 20 years, was detained by ICE in September 2025. He claims to be held in poor conditions at Fort Bliss, Texas, despite having a work permit and pending green card application. His case has drawn Irish political attention.
What's behind the headline?
The case of Seamus Culleton highlights the ongoing issues within US immigration enforcement. Despite having a valid work permit and a pending green card, his detention underscores how immigration laws can override individual circumstances. The conditions he reports—locked in a tent with limited sanitation, food, and sunlight—are inhumane and reflect systemic flaws. This story exposes the tension between US immigration policies aimed at deporting overstayers and the reality of long-term residents who contribute to society. The Irish government’s involvement indicates diplomatic pressure, but the broader implications suggest that US immigration enforcement remains unpredictable and often harsh, especially for non-criminal migrants. The case foreshadows potential diplomatic fallout and raises questions about the fairness of detention practices, especially for individuals with strong ties to the US.
What the papers say
The Irish Times, Sky News, NY Post all report on Culleton's detention, but with contrasting tones. The Irish Times emphasizes diplomatic efforts and the inhumane conditions, quoting his sister and wife, and highlighting the systemic issues. Sky News provides detailed personal accounts, describing the detention conditions vividly and calling it 'torture,' with a focus on his long-term life in the US and his hopes for intervention. The NY Post, while covering the story, emphasizes the personal determination of Culleton and the political pressure from Ireland, framing it as a diplomatic concern. The divergence reflects different editorial angles: one focusing on human rights, another on personal resilience, and the third on diplomatic implications.
How we got here
Culleton arrived in the US in 2009 under the visa waiver program and overstayed his tourist visa. He later married a US citizen, which allowed him to apply for a green card and obtain a work permit. Despite this, ICE detained him after a routine stop, citing his overstayed visa. His detention has sparked controversy over US immigration policies and treatment of long-term legal residents.
Go deeper
More on these topics