What's happened
An AP investigation reveals that SafeSport hesitated to impose a permanent ban on coach Sean Gardner, despite his willingness to admit abuse. Gardner, facing federal child pornography charges, was suspended in 2022 but remains eligible to work, raising concerns about internal politics and delayed justice.
What's behind the headline?
The SafeSport case exposes systemic flaws in how abuse allegations are handled within Olympic sports. Despite clear evidence and a willingness from Gardner to accept a lifetime ban, SafeSport's internal politics and fear of retaliation prevented swift, decisive action. This delay allowed Gardner to remain in positions of influence, potentially endangering more athletes. The case highlights the critical need for transparent, firm sanctions that send a clear message: abuse will be permanently barred, regardless of internal resistance. The failure to impose a permanent ban undermines SafeSport’s mission and risks eroding public trust in athlete protection mechanisms. Moving forward, reforms must prioritize accountability and eliminate internal barriers that hinder swift justice, ensuring that abusers are permanently removed from sports environments and that victims’ safety is paramount.
What the papers say
The AP investigation, as reported by AP News and The Independent, details SafeSport's internal delays and political struggles that prevented a permanent ban on Sean Gardner. The articles highlight that Gardner was willing to accept a lifetime ban in early 2025, but internal resistance and fear of retaliation within SafeSport delayed this action. Critics argue this failure undermines the agency’s core mission of protecting athletes. SafeSport spokesperson Hilary Nemchik stated that swift action was taken upon receiving allegations, but did not comment on specific delays. The articles also note Gardner's continued employment in healthcare roles despite suspension, raising questions about enforcement and oversight. The coverage contrasts SafeSport’s official stance with internal reports of dysfunction and retaliation, illustrating systemic issues that hinder effective athlete protection.
How we got here
Sean Gardner was sanctioned by SafeSport in 2022 after allegations of misconduct, but a permanent ban was not finalized. He was later arrested in August 2025 on child pornography charges. SafeSport's internal politics and fear of retaliation reportedly delayed harsher sanctions, allowing Gardner to continue working in different roles despite ongoing investigations and lawsuits.
Go deeper
Common question
-
Why Has SafeSport Delayed the Lifetime Ban for the Abuser?
Recent investigations reveal that SafeSport has delayed imposing a lifetime ban on coach Sean Gardner, despite his admission of misconduct and serious charges. This raises questions about internal politics, justice for victims, and athlete safety. Below, we explore the reasons behind these delays and what they mean for the sports community.
More on these topics
-
Lawrence Gerard Nassar is a former USA Gymnastics national team doctor, a former osteopathic physician and professor at Michigan State University College of Human Medicine, and a convicted sex offender.
-
United States of America Gymnastics (USA Gymnastics or USAG) is the national governing body for gymnastics in the United States. It sets the domestic rules and policies that govern the sport, promotes and develops gymnastics on the grassroots and national
-
The United States Center for SafeSport is an American 501c nonprofit organization set up in 2017 under the auspices of the Protecting Young Victims from Sexual Abuse and Safe Sport Authorization Act of 2017.