What's happened
As the 2025 GCSE exam season progresses, discussions about abolishing the exams gain momentum. Critics highlight their outdated nature, excessive stress on students, and a high failure rate. Meanwhile, in China, AI tools are disabled during the gaokao exams to prevent cheating, underscoring the high stakes of these assessments.
What's behind the headline?
The Case Against GCSEs
- Outdated Structure: Critics argue that GCSEs no longer serve their intended purpose, as most students continue their education until 18. The exams are seen as a relic of a bygone era.
- Financial Burden: The GCSE system is a billion-pound industry, with more money spent on exam entries than on educational resources, raising questions about resource allocation.
- Standardized Grading Issues: The bell curve grading system results in a significant number of students receiving below-average results, which can negatively impact their self-esteem and future opportunities.
- Mental Health Concerns: The high-stakes nature of GCSEs contributes to increased anxiety among students, particularly in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic.
- Calls for Reform: Prominent figures, including former education secretary Kenneth Baker, advocate for a new qualification framework that better reflects students' abilities and prepares them for future education or vocational training.
What the papers say
Sally Weale in The Guardian highlights the growing calls for abolishing GCSEs, noting that even their original architect, Kenneth Baker, now supports this view. Weale points out that the exams create unnecessary stress and do not accurately reflect students' knowledge or abilities. In contrast, Helen Davidson's reporting on the gaokao exams in China illustrates how technology is being used to maintain fairness during high-stakes assessments, with AI tools being disabled to prevent cheating. This reflects a broader societal emphasis on the importance of these exams in determining students' futures. The juxtaposition of these two educational systems raises questions about the effectiveness and relevance of standardized testing in today's educational landscape.
How we got here
Introduced in 1986, GCSEs replaced the O-level and CSE systems in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland. Over the years, they have faced criticism for their structure, high-stakes nature, and the stress they impose on students, especially as education now extends to age 18.
Go deeper
- What are the alternatives to GCSEs?
- How do other countries assess students?
- What impact does this have on students' futures?
Common question
-
Why Are Calls to Abolish GCSEs Gaining Momentum?
As the debate around the future of education intensifies, many are questioning the relevance and effectiveness of GCSEs. Critics argue that these exams are outdated and contribute to unnecessary stress for students. This raises further questions about what alternatives exist and how education systems in other countries compare.
More on these topics
-
Alibaba Group Holding Limited is a Chinese multinational technology company specializing in e-commerce, retail, Internet, and technology.
-
Tencent Holdings Ltd is a Chinese multinational conglomerate holding company, founded in 1998, whose subsidiaries specialise in various Internet-related services and products, entertainment, artificial intelligence and technology globally.
-
China, officially the People's Republic of China, is a country in East Asia. It is the world's most populous country, with a population of around 1.4 billion in 2019.