Man City found guilty by panel

What's happened

An independent commission has found Manchester City guilty of the vast majority of 115 Premier League financial-rule charges covering 2009–18, multiple outlets have reported. Sanctions have not been decided. City has said the process remains ongoing, has vowed to appeal and has told supporters the club will defend its position. (08 Oct 2026)

What's behind the headline?

What happened and why it matters

• An independent commission has found Manchester City guilty of most of 115 charges the Premier League brought over alleged financial breaches from 2009–18. The panel’s decision has not yet produced sanctions. City has said the process remains ongoing and will appeal.

Immediate effects

• The verdict will force the Premier League and the commission to decide sanctions that range from fines to points deductions or expulsion. Any heavy penalty will trigger legal challenges and further appeals that will stretch the dispute into months.

Who stands to gain or lose

• Rival clubs stand to gain financially or competitively if City lose points, places or titles; they are already seeking legal advice about compensation. City’s players, staff and commercial partners will lose certainty and face contract and transfer disruption while appeals proceed.

Longer-term consequences

• This will increase pressure on the Premier League to clarify governance and investigatory timelines. It will also force clubs and regulators to reassess how sponsorship and owner-linked funds are audited and reported.

Likely next steps

• City will appeal and the commission will publish its recommended sanctions for the Premier League to consider. Courts are likely to become involved if either side challenges procedural points or the application of penalties.

Bottom line

• The verdict has already altered the competitive and legal landscape of English football. The practical outcomes — stripped titles, points cuts or relegation — will be decided in the coming months and will reshape club finances and competition places across the league.

How we got here

The Premier League charged City in February 2023 after leaked documents prompted a four‑year probe. A three‑person independent hearing ran in late 2024 and has now produced a verdict that City breached rules on financial reporting, player payments and cooperation with investigators between 2009 and 2018. The club denies wrongdoing and has lodged an appeal.

Our analysis

The reporting shows broad agreement on the core facts but frames consequences differently. The Athletic and the New York Times report that the independent panel found City guilty on nearly all charges and that sanctions remain undecided; The Athletic quoted anonymous sources to say City were found guilty on 114 of 115 counts, while the New York Times noted the panel’s decision and City’s intention to appeal. BBC coverage has emphasised process and detail, listing the 115 charges and reminding readers the hearing began in September 2024 and that City have consistently denied wrongdoing. For example, BBC Sport said the charges include "54 x failure to provide accurate financial information" and that "City will appeal"; it also noted the club’s statement that the "process remains ongoing, with significant elements to be completed". The Guardian and BBC have highlighted Pep Guardiola’s public support for the club: Guardiola posted that he is "here; more than ever" and "always will be behind my club," framing his attendance at upcoming matches as a show of backing for City’s hierarchy. Al Jazeera and AP set out potential punishments and the wider stakes, with Al Jazeera noting rivals' legal moves and the range of possible sanctions from fines to expulsion. The BBC and The Guardian explored the reputational and historical consequences, asking whether past trophies belong in doubt; BBC analyses quantified City’s transfer spending and the flow of money to other clubs between 2009–18. Together, these sources establish (1) a commission verdict of guilt on most counts, (2) no sanctioned penalties announced yet, (3) City’s denial and planned appeal, and (4) a cascade of sporting, legal and financial consequences now set in motion.

Go deeper

• What sanctions will the commission recommend and when will they be announced?
• How will an appeal affect Manchester City's fixtures and player contracts?
• Which rival clubs are preparing legal claims for compensation?

More on these topics

• Premier League - Football league

  The Premier League, often referred to as the English Premier League or the EPL outside England, is the top level of the English football league system.

• Manchester City Football Club - Football club

  Manchester City Football Club is an English football club based in Manchester that competes in the Premier League, the top flight of English football. Founded in 1880 as St. Mark's, it became Ardwick Association Football Club in 1887 and Manchester City i

• Der Spiegel - German weekly news magazine based in Hamburg

  Der Spiegel (German pronunciation: [deːɐ̯ ˈʃpiːɡl̩], lit. 'The Mirror', stylized in all caps) is a German weekly news magazine published in Hamburg. With a weekly circulation of about 724,000 copies in 2022, it is one of the largest such publications in Europe. It was founded in 1947 by John Seymour Chaloner, a British army officer, and Rudolf Augstein, a former Wehrmacht radio operator who was recognized in 2000 by the International Press Institute as one of the fifty World Press Freedom Heroes. Der Spiegel is known in German-speaking countries mostly for its investigative journalism. It has played a key role in uncovering many political scandals, such as the Spiegel affair in 1962 and the Flick affair in the 1980s. The news website by the same name was launched in 1994 under the name Spiegel Online with an independent editorial staff. Today, the content is created by a shared editorial team, and the website uses the same media brand as the printed magazine.

• British Broadcasting Corporation - Broadcasting company

  The British Broadcasting Corporation is a British public service broadcaster. Headquartered at Broadcasting House in Westminster, London, it is the world's oldest national broadcaster, and the largest broadcaster in the world by number of employees.

• Erling Haaland - Norwegian footballer

  Erling Braut Haaland is a Norwegian professional footballer who plays as a striker for Bundesliga club Borussia Dortmund and the Norway national team.

• Roberto Mancini - Italian football manager

  Roberto Mancini is an Italian football manager and former player who is manager of the Italy national team. He is nicknamed Il Mancio.

• Abu Dhabi United Group - Company

  The Abu Dhabi United Group for Development and Investment, is a United Arab Emirates based private equity company. It is owned by Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, member of the Abu Dhabi Royal Family and Minister of Presidential Affairs for the UAE.

• Abu Dhabi - Capital of the United Arab Emirates

  Abu Dhabi is the capital and the second-most populous city of the United Arab Emirates. The city of Abu Dhabi is located on an island in the Persian Gulf, off the Central West Coast.

• The Athletic - Website

  The Athletic is a subscription-based sports website covering professional and college teams in over 20 other North American cities.

• e& - Abu Dhabi-based multinational telecom provider

  e& (read: "e and"), formerly Etisalat, is an Emirati joint-stock telecommunications company. It is currently the 16th largest in the world by subscribers. On 31 December 2021, Etisalat reported consolidated revenue of AED 53.3 billion and net profits of AED 11.1 billion. The total market capitalization of the company currently is AED329 billion. In May 2023, Etisalat reported revenue of AED 13 billion for Q1, AED 13.6 Billion for Q2, AED 13.3 Billion for Q3, and AED 13.7 Billion for Q4. In 2024, the revenue was AED 14.2 Billion for Q1, AED 14 Billion for Q2, AED 14.4 Billion for Q3, and AED 16.4 Billion for Q4. In 2025, E& reported annual revenue of AED 72.9 billion respectively. Etisalat is one of the main Internet hubs in the Middle East (AS8966), providing connectivity to other telecommunications operators in the region. It is also the largest carrier of international voice traffic in the Middle East and Africa combined and the 12th largest voice carrier in the world. As of October 2008, Etisalat has 510 roaming agreements covering a total of 186 countries and enabling BlackBerry, 3G, GPRS and voice roaming. Etisalat operates Points of Presence (PoP) in cities such as New York,...

• Enzo Maresca - Italian former footballer

  Vincenzo 'Enzo' Maresca is an Italian former footballer who played as a midfielder, and is the current Parma manager. After starting out at West Bromwich Albion in 1998, he went on to play for several clubs in his country, including Juventus, who loaned h

• Pep Guardiola - Spanish football manager

  Josep "Pep" Guardiola Sala is a Spanish professional football manager and former player, who is the current manager of Premier League club Manchester City. He is considered to be one of the greatest managers of all time.

• Manchester - City in England

  Manchester is a city and metropolitan borough in Greater Manchester, England. It has a population of 547,627 as of 2018. It lies within the United Kingdom's second-most populous urban area, with a population of 2.5 million and third-most populous metropol

• Manchester United F.C. - Football club

  Manchester United Football Club is a professional football club based in Old Trafford, Greater Manchester, England, that competes in the Premier League, the top flight of English football.

• Nottingham Forest F.C. - Football club

  Nottingham Forest Football Club, often referred to as Forest, are a professional football club based in West Bridgford, Nottinghamshire, England.

• Etihad Airways - Airline

  Etihad Airways is the second-largest airline and flag carrier of the UAE, after Emirates. Its head office is in Khalifa City, Abu Dhabi, near Abu Dhabi's International Airport. Etihad commenced operations in November 2003.

• Everton F.C. - Football club

  Everton Football Club is an English professional football club based in Liverpool that competes in the Premier League, the top tier of English football.

• Court of Arbitration for Sport - District justice in Lausanne, Switzerland

  The Court of Arbitration for Sport is an international body established in 1984 to settle disputes related to sport through arbitration. Its headquarters are in Lausanne and its courts are located in New York City, Sydney and Lausanne. Temporary courts ar

• Chelsea Football Club - Football club

  Chelsea Football Club are an English professional football club based in Fulham, London. Founded in 1905, the club competes in the Premier League, the top division of English football.

• Liverpool F.C. - Football club

  Liverpool Football Club is a professional football club in Liverpool, England, that competes in the Premier League, the top tier of English football.

• United Arab Emirates - Country in the Middle East

  The United Arab Emirates, sometimes simply called the Emirates, is a sovereign state in Western Asia at the northeast end of the Arabian Peninsula on the Persian Gulf, bordering Oman to the east and Saudi Arabia to the south and west, as well as sharing m

• Arsenal F.C. - Football club

  Arsenal Football Club is a professional football club based in Islington, London, England, that plays in the Premier League, the top flight of English football.

• Liverpool - City in England

  Liverpool is a city and metropolitan borough in Merseyside, England. Its population in 2019 was approximately 498,042. making it the tenth-largest English district by population and the largest in Merseyside and the surrounding region.

• Ferran Soriano - Chief Executive Officer of Manchester City

  Ferran Soriano i Compte is a Spanish businessman who is the chief executive officer of the Premier League club Manchester City F.C.. He also operates in the same role for Major League Soccer's New York City F.C., and the A-League's Melbourne City FC. Betw

• Kevin De Bruyne - Footballer

  Kevin De Bruyne is a Belgian professional footballer who plays as a midfielder for Premier League club Manchester City and the Belgian national team.

• BBC Sport

  BBC Sport is the sports division of the BBC, providing national sports coverage for BBC Television, radio and online. The BBC holds the television and radio UK broadcasting rights to several sports, broadcasting the sport live or alongside flagship analys

• Paris Saint-Germain - Football club

  Paris Saint-Germain Football Club, commonly referred to as Paris Saint-Germain, Paris SG, or simply Paris or PSG, is a French professional football club based in Paris. They compete in Ligue 1, the top division of French football.

• Queens Park Rangers F.C. - Football club

  Queens Park Rangers Football Club, commonly abbreviated to QPR, is an English professional football club based in White City, London. The club currently competes in the Championship, the second tier of English football.

• Union of European Football Associations - League

  The Union of European Football Associations is the administrative body for association football, futsal and beach soccer in Europe, although several member states are primarily or entirely located in Asia.

• Rio Ferdinand - English association football player (born 1978)

  Rio Gavin Ferdinand (born 7 November 1978) is an English former professional footballer who played as a centre-back, and is now a television pundit for BT Sport. He played 81 times for the England national team between 1997 and 2011, and was a member...

• FA Cup - Football cup

  The FA Cup, known officially as The Football Association Challenge Cup, is an annual knockout football competition in men's domestic English football. First played during the 1871–72 season, it is the oldest national football competition in the world. I

• City Football Group - Holding company

  City Football Group Limited is a British-based holding company that administers association football clubs. The group is owned by three organisations; of which 78% is majority owned by the Abu Dhabi United Group, 10% by the American firm Silver Lake and 1

• Burnley F.C. - Football club

  Burnley Football Club is an English association football club based in Burnley, Lancashire. Founded on 18 May 1882, it was one of the first to become professional, and subsequently put pressure on the Football Association to permit payments to players.

• The Guardian - Newspaper

  The Guardian is a British daily newspaper. It was founded in 1821 as The Manchester Guardian, and changed its name in 1959. Along with its sister papers The Observer and The Guardian Weekly, The Guardian is part of the Guardian Media Group, owned by the S