What's happened
A German historian used AI, historical records, and personal accounts to identify a Nazi executioner from a WWII photo taken in Ukraine over 80 years ago. The investigation revealed the executioner as Jakobus Onnen, linked to mass killings in 1941, with plans to identify the victim.
What's behind the headline?
The use of AI in historical investigations marks a significant shift in uncovering Nazi war crimes. Matthäus emphasizes that AI is a tool, not a replacement for human judgment, but its application here demonstrates how technology can enhance accuracy in identifying perpetrators. The revelation that the massacre occurred in Berdychiv rather than Vinnitsa revises historical understanding and underscores the importance of precise location data in Holocaust studies. The identification of Onnen, a low-ranking but committed Nazi, highlights the ongoing effort to bring accountability for war crimes. This case exemplifies how AI can complement traditional research, potentially leading to more discoveries and justice for victims. The story also raises questions about the future of historical justice, where AI could help identify other unknown perpetrators or victims, shaping a new era of accountability.
What the papers say
The Guardian reports that AI played a crucial role in solving the mystery, with historian Jürgen Matthäus stating that the match was 'unusually high' in confidence. The study published in the Journal of Historical Studies confirms the location as Berdychiv and details Onnen's background, including his Nazi involvement. The South China Morning Post highlights how family tips and open-source analysis contributed to the identification, emphasizing the collaborative nature of modern historical investigations. The Japan Times echoes this, noting the broader implications of AI in uncovering Nazi looting and war crimes, with Post's discovery linking to ongoing legal investigations in Argentina. Contrasting perspectives focus on AI as a powerful tool versus the importance of human judgment, with Matthäus stressing that AI is 'not the silver bullet' but part of a broader investigative process.
How we got here
The photo, taken during WWII in Ukraine, depicts a Nazi soldier aiming a pistol at a kneeling man before a mass grave. For decades, the identity of the soldier remained unknown. The historian, Jürgen Matthäus, combined AI analysis with historical records and personal accounts to identify the executioner as Jakobus Onnen, a Nazi involved in mass executions in 1941. The discovery was aided by a family member’s tip and open-source analysis, highlighting the role of technology in historical justice.
Go deeper
More on these topics