What's happened
New York City’s education system struggles with poor academic results despite high spending, while demographic changes show declining secular enrollment and rising religious school attendance. Meanwhile, Israel and China face curriculum and demographic shifts impacting civic understanding and societal cohesion.
What's behind the headline?
Critical Analysis
The data reveals a disconnect between educational spending and student outcomes in NYC, where record expenditures have not translated into academic proficiency. The emphasis on diversity, equity, and social justice in the DOE’s vision appears to divert focus from core subjects like reading and math, which are essential for student success.
In Israel, the decline in secular students and the rise in ultra-Orthodox enrollment threaten the country’s social cohesion and economic future, especially given the concerns about inadequate preparation for modern society.
China’s demographic decline, exemplified by Sanqiao Primary School’s staff-to-student ratio and falling birth rates, signals a shrinking future workforce and potential economic slowdown. These shifts highlight how demographic and ideological priorities are reshaping education systems globally, often at the expense of foundational skills.
The common thread is that both the US and these other nations are experiencing the consequences of misaligned educational priorities—whether through ideological curricula or demographic shifts—that threaten long-term societal stability and economic vitality. Immediate policy adjustments focusing on core academic skills and demographic realities are essential to mitigate these risks.
What the papers say
The NY Post criticizes NYC’s education spending, highlighting poor academic results despite a $41 billion budget and emphasizing the ideological focus of the DOE’s Vision and Mission statements. Bloomberg reports demographic shifts in Israel, with declining secular enrollment and rising ultra-Orthodox attendance, driven by lower birth rates and emigration. The Times of Israel discusses Israel’s decision to remove key civics topics from exams, reflecting political struggles over the country’s democratic identity amid declining secular student numbers. The South China Morning Post highlights China’s demographic decline, with Sanqiao Primary School’s staff exceeding pupils and a nationwide drop in birth rates, raising concerns about future workforce and societal stability.
How we got here
NYC spends over $41 billion annually on education, yet student proficiency in reading and math remains low. The city’s curriculum emphasizes diversity and social justice over core academics. Meanwhile, Israel faces declining secular enrollment amid rising religious school attendance, and China reports a significant drop in birth rates and primary school enrollment, reflecting broader demographic trends.
Go deeper
Common question
-
Why Are Secular Students Declining in Israel?
Recent data shows a significant decline in secular first-graders in Israel, alongside a rise in religious school enrollment. This shift raises questions about societal changes, emigration patterns, and the future of Israeli society. What are the main reasons behind these demographic shifts, and what could they mean for the country's social fabric? Below, we explore the key factors influencing these trends and what they imply for the future.
-
Why is Israel changing its civics curriculum now?
Israel's recent decision to alter its civics curriculum has sparked widespread debate. Many wonder what prompted these changes and how they might impact the country's democracy and societal cohesion. With demographic shifts and political tensions at play, understanding the reasons behind this move is crucial. Below, we explore the key questions surrounding Israel's education reforms and their broader implications.
-
How Are Education Policies Reflecting Political Tensions Worldwide?
Across the globe, education systems are increasingly becoming a mirror of political struggles and societal shifts. From curriculum changes in Israel to debates over democracy and civic knowledge, these policies reveal much about a country's internal tensions. Curious about how education reflects broader political conflicts? Below, we explore key questions about the connection between education, politics, and societal change.
-
What Are the Key Political Changes in the US and Israel Right Now?
Recent developments in US and Israeli politics are shaping the future of both nations. From upcoming elections to education reforms, these changes raise important questions about democracy, societal shifts, and political power. Curious about what’s happening and what it means? Read on to explore the latest political headlines and their implications.
-
Why Are NYC Schools Struggling Despite High Spending?
New York City invests over $41 billion annually in education, yet many students still perform poorly in reading and math. This raises questions about how the money is being used and what challenges the schools face. Are the issues related to curriculum choices, demographic shifts, or other factors? Below, we explore the reasons behind these struggles and what they mean for students and parents.
More on these topics
-
Israel, formally known as the State of Israel, is a country in Western Asia, located on the southeastern shore of the Mediterranean Sea and the northern shore of the Red Sea.
-
The New York City Department of Education is the department of the government of New York City that manages the city's public school system.