What's happened
Lee Cronin's new horror film 'The Mummy' has been released, drawing criticism for its overlong runtime, tonal confusion, and lack of scares. Critics note it diverges from traditional mummy stories, focusing on gore and visual effects, but fails to deliver suspense or character depth. The film is part of Universal's effort to reboot classic monsters.
What's behind the headline?
The new 'The Mummy' is shifting away from traditional mummy stories by emphasizing gore and visual spectacle over narrative coherence. Cronin's focus on visceral effects and epic visuals reflects a desire to elevate monster movies to high-craft blockbusters, but this approach results in a film that is overlong and tonally inconsistent. The film's reliance on shock value and gore, rather than suspense or character development, diminishes its potential to genuinely terrify audiences. This will likely lead to a mixed reception, with critics questioning whether the film's visual ambition compensates for its storytelling shortcomings. The decision to label it as 'Lee Cronin's The Mummy' aims to elevate the director's profile, but it risks overhyping a film that ultimately underdelivers on its promise of innovation. The film's focus on shocking imagery and a convoluted plot will probably limit its appeal to horror purists and fans of Cronin's previous work, while alienating viewers seeking a more traditional or suspenseful horror experience. Overall, this will increase pressure on Universal to find a balance between visual spectacle and compelling storytelling in future monster movies.
What the papers say
The Guardian's Benjamin Lee criticizes the film for being overlong, tonally unsure, and not very scary, despite Cronin's visual talent. He notes that the film's reliance on gore and effects results in a disjointed experience that fails to deliver suspense or character depth. Conversely, the NY Post highlights the film's departure from traditional mummy stories, emphasizing its gruesome scenes and visual effects, but questions whether these elements constitute a smart update or just shock for shock's sake. Both sources agree that the film's focus on gore and spectacle overshadows storytelling, but while the Guardian criticizes its lack of scares, the NY Post points out its attempt to differentiate from previous versions, albeit unsuccessfully.
How we got here
Universal has been attempting to revive its classic monster franchises with smaller, smarter productions after the failure of Tom Cruise's 'The Mummy' in 2017. Lee Cronin, known for 'Evil Dead Rise,' has been chosen to direct this new take, which aims to be a darker, more intense horror film. The film's release follows a trend of studios experimenting with more graphic and ambitious horror adaptations of familiar characters.
Go deeper
More on these topics