What's happened
In late June 2025, LeMan magazine published a cartoon depicting Muslim and Jewish figures shaking hands amid war imagery, sparking protests and legal action in Turkey. Authorities arrested the cartoonist and senior staff on charges of insulting religious values. The magazine denies depicting the Prophet Muhammad and calls for press freedom protections amid rising tensions.
What's behind the headline?
Legal and Political Context
The arrests of LeMan's cartoonist and editors underscore Turkey's increasingly restrictive environment for media and expression. The government leverages laws like Article 216 of the Turkish Penal Code, criminalizing 'incitement to hatred and enmity,' to suppress content deemed offensive to religious sentiments.
Religious Sensitivities and Nationalism
The cartoon's depiction of figures interpreted as Prophets Muhammad and Moses shaking hands amid war imagery touched a raw nerve in a predominantly Muslim country where religious respect is tightly guarded. President Erdogan's framing of the cartoon as a 'clear provocation' signals the state's intent to assert control over religious discourse.
Media Freedom Under Pressure
LeMan's defense—that the cartoon portrayed a Muslim man named Muhammad, not the Prophet—highlights the fine line satirists walk in Turkey. The magazine's call for judicial protection and freedom of expression contrasts sharply with the government's punitive response, reflecting broader tensions in Turkish society.
Broader Implications
This incident will likely deepen polarization between government supporters and opposition voices advocating for press freedom. It also raises concerns about the shrinking space for critical and satirical media in Turkey, with potential chilling effects on artistic and journalistic expression.
Forecast
Expect continued legal proceedings against LeMan staff and heightened protests. The case may become a focal point for international human rights and press freedom advocates, while domestically it will reinforce the government's narrative on protecting religious values at the expense of dissenting voices.
What the papers say
The Independent's Maroosha Muzaffar details the cartoon's imagery and the swift government backlash, quoting Interior Minister Ali Yerlikaya's condemnation: "This is not press freedom. This is not freedom of expression." Al Jazeera reports on the formal investigation under charges of 'openly insulting religious values' and highlights LeMan's apology coupled with its insistence that the cartoon was misinterpreted. The Times of Israel provides context on the cartoon's content, noting the depiction of two figures greeting each other with traditional Muslim and Jewish salutations, and includes LeMan's editor-in-chief Tuncay Akgun's assertion that the image was "not a caricature of Prophet Muhammad." AP News offers detailed accounts of the arrests, including footage shared by the Interior Ministry showing the cartoonist and others being detained. The New Arab emphasizes the government's framing of the cartoon as a 'vile image' and the legal basis for the investigation under Article 216 of the Turkish Penal Code. Across these sources, the narrative oscillates between government condemnation and the magazine's defense, illustrating the polarized discourse on freedom of expression and religious respect in Turkey.
How we got here
Turkey has a history of strict laws against insulting religious values, often used to limit dissent. LeMan, a satirical magazine founded in 1991, published a controversial cartoon in June 2025 that reignited debates on freedom of expression amid Turkey's low press freedom ranking.
Go deeper
- What are the legal grounds for the arrests related to the cartoon?
- How has the Turkish government justified its response to the cartoon?
- What does this incident reveal about press freedom in Turkey?
Common question
-
What Happened to the Cartoonists Detained in Turkey?
On July 1, 2025, Turkey made headlines after the detention of three cartoonists from Leman magazine due to a controversial cartoon depicting religious figures. This incident raises important questions about freedom of expression, the limits of satire, and the public's reaction to perceived blasphemy. Below, we explore the key aspects of this unfolding story.
More on these topics
-
Ali Yerlikaya is a Turkish bureaucrat who has served as the Governor of Istanbul since 26 October 2018. Following the annulment of the March 2019 Istanbul mayoral election, Yerlikaya briefly served as the acting Mayor of Istanbul until a new successor was
-
Turkey, officially the Republic of Turkey, is a transcontinental country located mainly on the Anatolian peninsula in Western Asia, with a smaller portion on the Balkan peninsula in Southeastern Europe.
-
Istanbul is the largest city in Turkey, constituting the country's economic, cultural, and historical heart. With a population over 15 million, it is home to 18% of the population of Turkey. Istanbul is among the largest cities in Europe and in the world.