What's happened
The City of Perth is facing backlash over plans to replace the beloved Ore Obelisk, known as The Kebab, with a 7-meter astronaut statue. Critics argue the decision lacks cultural relevance and transparency, while supporters claim it will attract tourism. The original artwork has been in storage since 2021 due to safety concerns.
What's behind the headline?
Cultural Significance
- The Ore Obelisk, or The Kebab, is a local landmark with historical roots, representing Perth's growth.
- Critics argue that replacing it with a mass-produced statue undermines local artistry and heritage.
Public Sentiment
- A petition by Save the Kebab has garnered over 1,400 signatures, indicating strong community opposition.
- Prominent figures, including Janet Holmes à Court, have voiced their discontent, emphasizing the need for local representation in public art.
Economic Considerations
- Proponents of the astronaut statue argue it will enhance tourism and economic activity in Perth.
- The City of Perth claims the statue's installation is a low-cost investment for a potential tourist attraction, but critics question the long-term cultural implications.
Future Implications
- The outcome of this controversy may set a precedent for future public art projects in Perth and beyond, highlighting the balance between contemporary art and local heritage.
What the papers say
According to Kelly Burke in The Guardian, the City of Perth's decision to replace The Kebab with Boonji Spaceman has faced significant backlash, with critics labeling the astronaut statue as 'factory-produced space junk.' Helen Curtis, a spokesperson for Save the Kebab, criticized the lack of consultation with local elders and the arts advisory group, stating, 'The Boonji Spaceman has no place in Perth.' Meanwhile, the council defended its decision, claiming the new artwork relates to Perth's historical nickname as the 'City of Light' due to John Glenn's observation from space. This juxtaposition of local sentiment against council justification illustrates the ongoing tension between community values and urban development initiatives.
How we got here
The Ore Obelisk, created by Paul Ritter in 1971, was removed in 2021 after safety issues arose. The City of Perth announced plans to replace it with Boonji Spaceman, an American artwork, which has sparked significant public opposition and debate over cultural significance.
Go deeper
- What are the arguments for and against the new statue?
- How has the community reacted to the council's decision?
- What is the historical significance of The Kebab?
More on these topics