What's happened
Florida's education standards now emphasize instruction on anti-communist figures and efforts, softening the critique of McCarthyism. Critics argue the standards distort history, while supporters say they promote patriotism. The standards follow legislation signed by Governor DeSantis in 2024, including a Victims of Communism Day.
What's behind the headline?
The new Florida standards represent a significant shift in how American history, particularly the Cold War era, is taught. By framing McCarthyism as a patriotic effort and downplaying its repressive aspects, the standards risk rewriting a painful chapter of US history. This approach aligns with broader political efforts to promote anti-communist narratives, especially in regions with strong anti-communist sentiments like Miami's Cuban-American community. The standards' emphasis on propaganda and slander against anti-communists further distorts the historical record, potentially influencing future generations' understanding of civil liberties and political repression. This move consolidates a partisan narrative that may hinder critical thinking and historical accuracy, with long-term implications for education and democratic discourse. The controversy underscores the ongoing politicization of history education, raising concerns about the impact on students' ability to critically analyze past and present political movements.
What the papers say
AP News reports highlight the contrasting perspectives on Florida's new standards. Critics, including historian Ellen Schrecker and Mitzi Trumbo, argue the standards distort the history of McCarthyism and political repression, emphasizing that the movement was a widespread episode of repression. AP quotes Trumbo's daughter, who warns that rewriting history to match current political narratives undermines democratic values. Conversely, supporters, including Florida officials, defend the standards as necessary for patriotic education and to prevent indoctrination, citing the law signed by DeSantis and the state's emphasis on anti-communist efforts. The Independent echoes concerns about the standards softening the critique of McCarthyism, with experts warning it promotes a narrow, ideological view of history that could limit teachers' ability to address complex historical realities.
How we got here
The standards were prompted by a 2024 law signed by Governor DeSantis requiring instruction on the consequences of communism. They include teaching about figures like Mao Zedong and Fidel Castro, and efforts by anti-communist politicians. Critics, including historians and descendants of blacklisted figures, argue the standards distort the history of McCarthyism and political repression in the US.
Go deeper
More on these topics
-
Ronald "Ron" Dion DeSantis is an American attorney, naval officer, and Republican politician. He has served as the 46th governor of Florida since 2019, and he represented Florida's 6th congressional district in Congress from 2013 to 2018.
-
Joseph Raymond McCarthy was an American politician who served as a Republican U.S. Senator from the state of Wisconsin from 1947 until his death in 1957.
-
James Dalton Trumbo was an American screenwriter who scripted many award-winning films, including Roman Holiday, Exodus, Spartacus, and Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo.