What's happened
On October 28, 2025, Donald Trump's legal team filed a detailed appeal challenging his 34-count conviction for falsifying business records related to hush money payments before the 2016 election. The appeal argues prosecutorial misconduct, judicial conflicts of interest, and misapplication of the Supreme Court's presidential immunity ruling. The case remains active in New York's appellate courts with potential escalation to the US Supreme Court.
What's behind the headline?
Legal Strategy and Implications
Trump's appeal hinges on the Supreme Court's 2024 immunity ruling, which shields presidents from prosecution for official acts. His lawyers contend that evidence related to his official duties was improperly admitted, warranting reversal. They also challenge the judge's impartiality due to political donations and family ties, arguing this compromised the trial's fairness.
Political Context and Timing
The appeal comes as Trump prepares for the 2024 presidential campaign, framing the prosecution as politically motivated. This narrative aims to galvanize his base and question the legitimacy of legal actions against him.
Judicial Process and Potential Outcomes
The case is currently before New York's Appellate Division, with possible escalation to the state's highest court and ultimately the US Supreme Court. Trump's legal team is also seeking to transfer the case to federal court, potentially expediting Supreme Court review.
Broader Impact
This appeal underscores the tension between state-level prosecutions and presidential immunity, setting precedents for future cases involving sitting or former presidents. The outcome will influence legal interpretations of executive privilege and political accountability.
What to Watch
- The Appellate Division's ruling on evidentiary and procedural claims.
- The federal appeals court's decision on jurisdictional transfer.
- Potential Supreme Court involvement and its implications for presidential immunity.
This case will shape the intersection of law and politics in the US for years to come.
What the papers say
Alex Woodward of The Independent details the legal arguments in a 111-page filing, highlighting claims that Manhattan prosecutors "concocted" charges and that the trial judge should have recused himself due to political donations and family conflicts. Woodward notes the conviction involved falsified business records linked to hush money payments and that Trump's legal team views the case as politically charged.
Jacob Shamsian at Business Insider UK emphasizes the role of Sullivan & Cromwell, Trump's elite law firm, which argues the case "should never have seen the inside of a courtroom." Shamsian reports that the appeal challenges the judge's jury instructions and the admission of evidence post-Supreme Court immunity ruling, with the legal team seeking a swift path to the US Supreme Court.
AP News provides a concise summary of the conviction and sentencing, noting Trump's unconditional discharge and denial of wrongdoing.
The NY Post frames the appeal as Trump's latest effort to overturn his guilty verdict and mentions his request to move the case to federal court, potentially allowing Supreme Court review.
Erik Larson at Bloomberg highlights the claim that felony charges were "manufactured" under a "convoluted legal theory" and the judge's alleged failure to recuse himself.
Politico reports on the 96-page filing reiterating previous arguments about presidential immunity and judicial impartiality, quoting the legal team stating, "This case should never have seen the inside of a courtroom."
Together, these sources provide a comprehensive view of the legal maneuvers, political context, and procedural complexities surrounding Trump's ongoing appeals.
How we got here
In May 2024, Trump was convicted of 34 felony counts for falsifying business records to conceal hush money paid to Stormy Daniels during his 2016 campaign. He was sentenced to an unconditional discharge in January 2025, avoiding jail or fines. The Supreme Court later issued a ruling on presidential immunity, complicating the legal landscape for Trump's appeals.
Go deeper
- What are the main legal arguments in Trump's appeal?
- How does the Supreme Court's immunity ruling affect this case?
- What could happen next in the appeals process?
Common question
-
What Is Donald Trump Appealing in His Business Fraud Case?
Donald Trump is currently challenging his recent conviction for falsifying business records related to hush money payments. His legal team argues that the case was politically motivated and improperly tried, raising questions about the impact of his appeal on the case's outcome. Many wonder what specific aspects Trump is contesting and how this could influence his legal and political future. Below, we explore the key questions surrounding Trump's legal appeal and its broader implications.
-
What Are the Biggest News Stories Today?
Stay informed with the latest headlines shaping the world today. From legal battles involving high-profile figures to international conflicts and technological debates, these stories are capturing attention worldwide. Curious about how these events impact politics, security, and everyday life? Below, we answer the most pressing questions about today's top news stories.
More on these topics
-
Donald John Trump is an American politician, media personality, and businessman who served as the 45th president of the United States from 2017 to 2021.
-
Alvin Leonard Bragg Jr. is an American lawyer and politician from the state of New York who previously served as Chief Deputy Attorney General in New York State Office of Attorney General.
-
Juan Manuel Merchan is an American judge and former prosecutor currently serving as an acting justice of the New York State Supreme Court in New York County. He is the judge for the 2024 criminal trial of former US president, Donald Trump.