What's happened
A review of a Hackney school reveals routine shaming and harsh discipline practices, including 'desking' punishments. Despite strong academic results, concerns about student wellbeing and inclusivity have prompted calls for reform. The Mossbourne Federation is reviewing the findings, with the Department for Education warning of serious issues.
What's behind the headline?
The review exposes a troubling disconnect between academic success and student wellbeing. Routine shaming tactics like shouting and 'desking' are not only damaging but also undermine trust and inclusivity. The school's leadership appears defensive, allowing harmful practices to persist without accountability. This suggests a systemic failure to balance discipline with respect, risking long-term harm to vulnerable students. The Department for Education's warning indicates that reforms are urgent; otherwise, the school's reputation and student welfare will continue to suffer. This case exemplifies how high performance can mask underlying issues, and it underscores the need for a cultural shift towards more humane discipline policies that prioritize mental health and inclusivity.
What the papers say
Sky News reports that despite the school's academic success, serious concerns about its disciplinary culture have emerged, with allegations of routine humiliation and harmful practices like 'desking.' The review criticizes leadership for failing to address these issues and highlights the school's defensive stance. The Independent details a separate case involving misconduct by a teacher, Andrew Bennington, who contacted a former pupil via social media, leading to his indefinite ban from teaching. Another incident involved teacher Benjamin Guilfoyle, who was prohibited from teaching after physically restraining a pupil improperly. These cases reflect broader concerns about safeguarding and professional conduct in education, contrasting with the focus on disciplinary culture at the Hackney school. While Sky News emphasizes systemic issues within the school, The Independent highlights individual misconduct cases, illustrating different facets of safeguarding challenges in UK education.
How we got here
The review was prompted by longstanding concerns about disciplinary methods at the Hackney school, which was rated 'outstanding' by Ofsted in 2023. The investigation uncovered practices like shouting and 'desking'—placing students in corridors as punishment—that have been linked to emotional harm, especially for vulnerable pupils. The school’s success in academics contrasted sharply with these disciplinary issues, raising questions about the true cost of its achievements.
Go deeper
More on these topics