What's happened
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has opened a preliminary investigation into Comma AI devices after five crashes in which users’ cars collided with slow or stopped vehicles. At least three people have died and 11 injured across the incidents. Forked versions of the software may be involved, and regulators are checking the software running in each crash.
What's behind the headline?
Analysis
- What this means for drivers: safety regulators are scrutinizing how well OpenPilot detects stationary vehicles in its lane, and whether forks of the software altered performance.
- What is changing: regulators are reviewing which version of the software operated in each crash and whether modified forks contributed to failures.
- Who benefits: established automakers and safety advocates press for clearer standards; hobbyist developers push for openness and continued innovation.
- Forecast: expect intensified ODI oversight, potential recalls, and tighter requirements for driver-monitoring features. This will likely push more carmakers to advance built-in ADAS rather than aftermarket solutions.
Key quotes
How we got here
Comma.ai produces OpenPilot and aftermarket devices installed in hundreds of car models. Founded by George Hotz, the company has faced regulatory scrutiny for years as its open-source software evolved into consumer hardware that enables driver-assistance features. The current ODI probe follows earlier inquiries into autonomous systems and the company’s software forks.
Our analysis
Business Insider UK: The ODI has confirmed the systems were powered on in multiple crashes and that some vehicles may have used forks of OpenPilot. Ars Technica: Five crashes and three deaths are linked to comma.ai devices; regulators seek details on software versions. TechCrunch: ODI notes crashes involved devices failing to detect slow or stopped vehicles; some crashes involved forked software such as FrogPilot.
Go deeper
- What safety standards govern aftermarket ADAS devices?
- Will this lead to a recall or redesign of OpenPilot forks?
More on these topics
-
George Hotz - American software engineer
George Francis Hotz, alias GeoHot, is an American security hacker, entrepreneur, and software engineer. He is known for developing iOS jailbreaks, reverse engineering the PlayStation 3, and for the subsequent lawsuit brought against him by Sony.
-
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration - Agency
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration is an agency of the U.S. federal government, part of the Department of Transportation.
-
Autopilot - Advanced driver-assistance system available in some Tesla vehicles
Tesla Autopilot is a suite of advanced driver-assistance system features offered by Tesla that amounts to Level 2 vehicle automation.
-
Tesla, Inc. - Vehicle manufacturer
Tesla, Inc. is an American electric vehicle and clean energy company based in Palo Alto, California. The company specializes in electric vehicle manufacturing, battery energy storage from home to grid scale and, through its acquisition of SolarCity, solar
-
Toyota RAV4 - Compact crossover SUV
The Toyota RAV4 (Japanese: トヨタ・RAV4, Hepburn: Toyota Ravufō) is a compact crossover SUV produced by the Japanese automobile manufacturer Toyota. Having sold over 15 million units worldwide as of 2025, the RAV4 is the best-selling SUV of all time. The car is credited with popularizing compact crossover automobiles, often credited as the first modern compact crossover SUV. In February 2025, the RAV4 replaced the Ford F-150 as the best-selling car in the United States, after nearly four decades of the latter's reign. It made its debut in Japan and Europe in 1994, and in North America in 1995, being launched in January 1996. The vehicle was designed for consumers wanting a vehicle that had most of the benefits of SUVs, such as increased cargo room, higher visibility, and the option of full-time four-wheel drive, along with the maneuverability of a mid-size car. The vehicle's name is an abbreviation of "Recreational Active Vehicle with 4-wheel drive", (occasionally "Robust Accurate Vehicle with 4-wheel drive"), although not all models come equipped with the four-wheel drive system. For the third-generation model, Toyota offered both short- and long-wheelbase versions of the RAV4. Short-wheelbase...
-
Louisiana - US State
Louisiana is a state in the Deep South region of the South Central United States. It is the 19th-smallest by area and the 25th most populous of the 50 U.S. states.